American Idol: Season 7!!

Erika

Moderator
A Daughtry wannabe, a Fantasia wannabe and an Aiken wannabe are unique?

Hmmm, maybe the definition changed.

I don't see the Fantasia similarity at all. :shrug:

Actually I think the Aiken is a bit of a stretch as well although I concede that they probably do have the same audience.
 

Legacy

Well-Known Member
I don't see the Fantasia similarity at all. :shrug:

Actually I think the Aiken is a bit of a stretch as well although I concede that they probably do have the same audience.

Fantasia = Power-note belter.

Syeesha = Power-note attempter.

I liked her earlier when she did more intimate stuff, but personally, every attempt at Proud Mary screams, "I wanna be like Tina Turner!"

The Aiken comparison comes from having a dorky looking kid who does feel-good, "Power to the People" ballads while 12-year-old girls squeal.

But what do I know... AI is an amazing 33% on the best singer actually winning (2 out of 6 for those playing at home; Clarkson and Underwood) and Archuleta winning this year will put them at an colossal 42% (3 out of 7). But if you count out Archuleta because he's done a similar thing five years ago... that would put them at 29% (2 out of 7).
 

Monty

Brilliant...and Canadian
In the Parks
No
Hooray! Goodbye Jason, and take those ugly, smelly dreds with you! :sohappy:
You been sniffing Jason's locks dude? :hurl:

I am happy to see the American public has redeemed itself somewhat...


Now, if you could all just elect someone competent to lead your country. :lookaroun


[OK, mebbe we'll wait four years for a shot at that, will we? :rolleyes:]
 

Erika

Moderator
Fantasia = Power-note belter.

Syeesha = Power-note attempter.

I liked her earlier when she did more intimate stuff, but personally, every attempt at Proud Mary screams, "I wanna be like Tina Turner!"

The Aiken comparison comes from having a dorky looking kid who does feel-good, "Power to the People" ballads while 12-year-old girls squeal.

But what do I know... AI is an amazing 33% on the best singer actually winning (2 out of 6 for those playing at home; Clarkson and Underwood) and Archuleta winning this year will put them at an colossal 42% (3 out of 7). But if you count out Archuleta because he's done a similar thing five years ago... that would put them at 29% (2 out of 7).

Kelly was a power belter as well. Fantasia is very raspy, Syesha is very clear- I still don't buy the comparison, sorry :lol:

You know way too much about Idol for being a non-fan :p
 

SweetMagic

Oh Meyla Weyla
I think American Idol would be the least of His concerns...

It may not be His concern, it may be His hobby, however :)

Kelly was a power belter as well. Fantasia is very raspy, Syesha is very clear- I still don't buy the comparison, sorry :lol:

You know way too much about Idol for being a non-fan :p

Agreed, and as far as Clay Aiken, he may have turned into a suspicious character since his Idol days, but I'll take his voice over Archuletta any day.
 

wdwmomof3

Well-Known Member
Is anyone else counting the days till So You Think You Can Dance?

I can get so much more into that than Idol.

Yes!! I have never really watched it but I am going to this year. It looks like a lot of fun.

Back to Idol,

YES, he's gone!! :sohappy::sohappy::sohappy::sohappy::sohappy::sohappy::sohappy:
 

TurboCaroline

Is it 5:00 yet?
Original Poster
A Daughtry wannabe, a Fantasia wannabe and an Aiken wannabe are unique?

Hmmm, maybe the definition changed.
I love Daughtry but I think David Cook is more talented...:shrug: He has more range in his voice than Chris...we'll see how his first album sells. I know I will be first in line to get it..:D
 

k.hunter30

New Member
Is anyone else counting the days till So You Think You Can Dance?

I can get so much more into that than Idol.
I love that show except for the screaming lady. She's just obnoxious.

So... I LOVE Adam Levine, I have for quite some years now. LOVE him. But did anyone else get the feeling that he was... hopped up on something...:lookaroun He seemed quite... wired.
 

mpoppins76

Well-Known Member
Hey, during AI last night, our local FOX channel was showing news teasers and they said something about "2 previous AI finalists who are now a couple and will be heading down the aisle soon." Tried to stay up for the news but fell asleep before they had that part on. :eek::hammer:
Anyone else hear about this? :shrug:
 

Erika

Moderator
Hey, during AI last night, our local FOX channel was showing news teasers and they said something about "2 previous AI finalists who are now a couple and will be heading down the aisle soon." Tried to stay up for the news but fell asleep before they had that part on. :eek::hammer:
Anyone else hear about this? :shrug:

oooooooOOOOOOOOooo, interesting! This is the first I've heard.
 

Erika

Moderator
VFTW does good recaps.
So which are you admitting to- quoting someone else's opinion as your own, or watching the show PLUS reading up on VFTW.

:ROFLOL:

I say this all in fun.

I wonder if I've ever devoted this much time to something I didn't even like.
scratchchin6hy.gif
Maybe I have, I just can't think of anything right now. :lol: :shrug:
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom