American Idol: Season 7!!

Coree

Coree

Well-Known Member
If Jason doesn't go after this week I'm seriously giving up on Idol! Simon was right that Jason's performance was pretty wretched.
 
F

Fantasmic!329

Active Member
Jason was a complete train wreck tonight if I ever saw one. :eek: :ROFLOL: :ROFLOL:
Syesha and David A. were both very good, IMHO.
David C. - I hated his first song, and his second one wasn't much better. :shrug:
 
Coree

Coree

Well-Known Member
I agree that Syesha did a really good job tonight. She has been getting better every week (not worse like some people . . . ahem, Jason). I've been a big David A. fan all along. I thought he did a great job on his first song. I wasn't as impressed as the judges by his second one, but he still did a good job. I've also been liking David C. I didn't think his first song was great, but really liked the second.

I just have to hope that the sane voting public overrules the teen girls and vote-for-the worst followers this week to finally oust Jason. :hammer:
 
Monty

Monty

Brilliant...and Canadian
In the Parks
No
David C - first not great, second wonderful
David A - first wonderful, second not great
Syesha - both fairly good
Jason - could have mailed in his first, it wasn't good enough to be on the bad auditions shows. His second might have been OK had he remembered the words. Of course Dylan has a voice that hasn't always been perfect, so it was a good choice that way :rolleyes:
 
brianheather

brianheather

Member
Loving That David Cook.... As Paula said weeks back... He could sing the phone book and I would listen... Jason Castro Made me laugh. I can't believe that you could perform that in front of millions of viewers and think that you did good. Simon is right "pack your suitcase".
David A bores me, he sings the same (safe) type of ballads each week, do something different.
 
Legacy

Legacy

Well-Known Member
Coree said:
If Jason doesn't go after this week I'm seriously giving up on Idol! Simon was right that Jason's performance was pretty wretched.
Click to expand...

You mean you haven't given up on it already?

Geesh, I gave up on the show four seasons ago when Jennifer Hudson got booted at number 8. The judges are all inept, the formula is unfair, and most viewers don't grasp how fake the show is.

All that said... GO JASON!
 
nibblesandbits

nibblesandbits

Well-Known Member
imagineer boy said:
I take it Simon didn't like Castro's performance. :lookaroun He's dead meat. There's no way he can stay after a review from simon like that. :sohappy:

BTW, David A was amazing!
Click to expand...
Well, let's just hope that Vote For the Worst doesn't have an effect on that. :fork: He was awful tonight and deserves to go.

David A was phenominal, Syesha was really good. David C...I thought his first song really was eh...but he did do much better on his second one. To me, based on tonight's performances, it should be Castro and Cook in the bottom 2...and of course Castro going home. However, I believe it will come down to Syesha and Castro...and let's just hope it's Castro going home. He's got another part of the teeny bopper vote...and they've been doing a good job of keeping him in.
 
SweetMagic

SweetMagic

Oh Meyla Weyla
SpongeScott said:
Castro looks, acts, and sounds like he doesn't even want to be on the show. Perhaps America will oblige tonight.
Click to expand...

I agree, his whole nonchalant attitude drives me nuts. It's like he either doesn't care, or he doesn't get that people who win this show actually make a few $$. Apparently he's not impressed :shrug:
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom