American Idol: Season 7!!

Shere_Khan

Shere_Khan

Well-Known Member
I think Carly was really upset about what Simon said about how she looks. It seemed like she was about to cry the whole time after his comment.
I like Simon, but I thought that was pretty rude.

I still love Jason although he has not been the best. I just genuinely like him as a person I think. And his songs are very sweet and emotional. I enjoy it.

Ramiele needs to go tonight and I'm sorry but I think Brooke should go soon. She is a good singer but she just does not have the range in her voice.
 
k.hunter30

k.hunter30

New Member
PeoplemoverTTA said:
Oh, and Scott, I don't like David Cook either. By all accounts I should, because he's really talented. One thing I don't like is that I feel he comes across as very cocky, and I don't like it. Sorry to all of you who like him. I just...don't :o
Click to expand...
See... that's been my issue all along as well. When they were in the other theater, he was one of the only guys who wouldn't stand in support of the girls while they were singing. I was like, who does he think he is? Anyways, he IS very talented. I just think he needs a taste of humble pie.
 
Shere_Khan

Shere_Khan

Well-Known Member
k.hunter30 said:
See... that's been my issue all along as well. When they were in the other theater, he was one of the only guys who wouldn't stand in support of the girls while they were singing. I was like, who does he think he is? Anyways, he IS very talented. I just think he needs a taste of humble pie.
Click to expand...

I don't care too much about David Cook. Although I did find his performance of Billie Jean to be outstanding.

What I can't stand is how when the judges are talking to Brooke she constantly talks and interrupts. From what I've read here, most of you seem to love her, so maybe I am the only one who is seeing this. LOL.
 
PeoplemoverTTA

PeoplemoverTTA

Well-Known Member
Shere_Khan said:
What I can't stand is how when the judges are talking to Brooke she constantly talks and interrupts. From what I've read here, most of you seem to love her, so maybe I am the only one who is seeing this. LOL.
Click to expand...

Actually, although I like her, I've noticed it...not only does she interrupt, but she constantly goes, "It's okay."

Um, well they're not really asking for your forgiveness :lol:
 
k.hunter30

k.hunter30

New Member
PeoplemoverTTA said:
Actually, although I like her, I've noticed it...not only does she interrupt, but she constantly goes, "It's okay."

Um, well they're not really asking for your forgiveness :lol:
Click to expand...
I thought the exact same thing. I love her, she's so cute and seems really sweet. But the "It's okay" thing when someone gives her criticism does rub me the wrong way.
 
E

Erika

Moderator
PeoplemoverTTA said:
Actually, although I like her, I've noticed it...not only does she interrupt, but she constantly goes, "It's okay."

Um, well they're not really asking for your forgiveness :lol:
Click to expand...

Oh, I have been reading that differently. I thought it was to keep the audience members in check (who boo after every criticism).
 
SpongeScott

SpongeScott

Well-Known Member
Shere_Khan said:
I think Carly was really upset about what Simon said about how she looks. It seemed like she was about to cry the whole time after his comment.
I like Simon, but I thought that was pretty rude.
Click to expand...
Not 15 seconds before Simon had said this, I said the same thing to Mrs. Sponge. Every week it's the same thing with her--some sort of a sleeveless top to show off the tat on her arm. We've seen it every week, we know what it looks like, it is time for a new look from her. Dressing the part also plays into this and she does need a change.

Once again, Simon is spot-on right, as he usually is. And if they can't take his criticism from the show, they are in the wrong business. I would imagine the music industry is pretty cut-throat.
 
k.hunter30

k.hunter30

New Member
SpongeScott said:
Not 15 seconds before Simon had said this, I said the same thing to Mrs. Sponge. Every week it's the same thing with her--some sort of a sleeveless top to show off the tat on her arm. We've seen it every week, we know what it looks like, it is time for a new look from her. Dressing the part also plays into this and she does need a change.

Once again, Simon is spot-on right, as he usually is. And if they can't take his criticism from the show, they are in the wrong business. I would imagine the music industry is pretty cut-throat.
Click to expand...
I ususally agree with most of what Simon says. Though last night, I just don't think he was really speaking what America was thinking, as he claims he does.
 
nibblesandbits

nibblesandbits

Well-Known Member
Erika said:
Oh, I have been reading that differently. I thought it was to keep the audience members in check (who boo after every criticism).
Click to expand...
I have too...that's exactly how I've been reading it. I haven't been seeing it as rude thing, but as a way to keep the audience more quiet so she can hear the criticism or something. But I've always thought it was to keep the audience in check.
 
TiggerBW

TiggerBW

Well-Known Member
ok time again to fill me in on the results! (please!) My hubby doesn't let me watch the results show. I turned it on seeing Reimiel sing so I guess she's off. Who else was in the bottom 3? Thanks so much!!!!!!!!!!! :wave:
 
GenerationX

GenerationX

Well-Known Member
k.hunter30 said:
I ususally agree with most of what Simon says. Though last night, I just don't think he was really speaking what America was thinking, as he claims he does.
Click to expand...
He said what our family was thinking. Carly's got a great voice, but she doesn't know how to dress herself and the tattoo looks stupid. On the plus side, she didn't make nearly as many hideous faces when she sang last night as she usually does.

Ramiele never found the right song to showcase her voice.

Archuleta still has this thing in the bag.
 
wdwmomof3

wdwmomof3

Well-Known Member
DisneyJill said:
:hurl::hurl:

I hate that guy more and more every week. :lookaroun

Next week...Kristy is gone. Oooh, or Jason. I hate that guy more and more every week too! :shrug:
Click to expand...

I think that Kristy will be gone next week too, and Jason the week after. I think that he is sweet and all but when I see him I think "duh", and I HATE his hair. :hurl:
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom