American Idol: Season 7!!

Fantasmic!329

Active Member
^ I have the exact opposite reaction.
I'm devestated that he got voted off. :cry:
I really liked him.
And he did not deserve to get voted off before Kristy and Syeshia.
Sorry to disagree.
I still love you, anyway. :lol: :kiss:
What I thought was terrible was that after telling Carly and Syesha they were safe, Ryan said, "As you know, last year we didn't send anyone home during Idol Gives Back Week.....(long pause) this week, we're saying goodbye to Michael Johns" (not an exact quote, but close).

I feel badly, because Kristy and Syesha definitely should have gone first.
Point 1: I'm sorry, but that was plain old mean of Ryan. I really think that was cruel, and Ryan should not have done that.
Point 2: Even though I hated Michael, I do think that he was stronger than Kristy and Syesha.
It wasn't his signing that bothered me; it was his attitude. He seemed cocky (not as bad as David C.), but still cocky.
 

k.hunter30

New Member
Sorry to disagree.
I still love you, anyway. :lol: :kiss:

Point 1: I'm sorry, but that was plain old mean of Ryan. I really think that was cruel, and Ryan should not have done that.
Point 2: Even though I hated Michael, I do think that he was stronger than Kristy and Syesha.
It wasn't his signing that bothered me; it was his attitude. He seemed cocky (not as bad as David C.), but still cocky.
Totally agree on that (though I didn't think Michael came accross as cocky...)
Did anyone else think that David C. was TRYING to act humble. When asked by Ryan what he thought his result would be he replied, "Hmm... either way." Then we he was told to go to the couch he just seemed to be overdoing the surprised-then-hanging-his-head-down-modestly thing...
It wasn't like the usual David C.
 

Computer Magic

Well-Known Member
Point 2: Even though I hated Michael, I do think that he was stronger than Kristy and Syesha.
It wasn't his signing that bothered me; it was his attitude. He seemed cocky (not as bad as David C.), but still cocky.
Michael demise was challenging Randy critique of his performance. The viewers don't like that. I remember watching Mondy and thinking that is not good. I thought he would overcome it and not be voted off, but once again history proves itself.

Even last night as Simon was giving him advice, Michael was shaking his head no.
 

SweetMagic

Oh Meyla Weyla
I'll miss Michael, I really liked him from very early on. I know he had a few not so stellar moments, but he was really very good at being a front man.

Oh well.

What I don't get is why the contestants are always told to show who they truly are, but then every time David C. shows who he is, Simon calls him arrogant or some such word. I think that causes David to act a bit more humble the next night in order to show that he's not what Simon thinks he is. :shrug:
 

GenerationX

Well-Known Member
Michael had many crappy weeks in a row, which must have eroded his fan base. It's only been in the last week or two that he was reasonably good, but apparently not enough to capture back the fans he lost to (my guess) David Cook.

What was even more surprising was the opening number - an unabashedly Christian song "Shout to the Lord". How did that get past the censors? Outside of Linus quoting the Gospel of Luke in A Charlie Brown Christmas (which I'm still amazed doesn't come with a viewer discretion warning), this is the most Christian reference I've seen this year on network TV. I'm sure someone has been fired.
 

TiggerBW

Well-Known Member
Michael had many crappy weeks in a row, which must have eroded his fan base. It's only been in the last week or two that he was reasonably good, but apparently not enough to capture back the fans he lost to (my guess) David Cook.

What was even more surprising was the opening number - an unabashedly Christian song "Shout to the Lord". How did that get past the censors? Outside of Linus quoting the Gospel of Luke in A Charlie Brown Christmas (which I'm still amazed doesn't come with a viewer discretion warning), this is the most Christian reference I've seen this year on network TV. I'm sure someone has been fired.

Well it was inspirational week and that would be an inspirational song. Inspirational to me is Christian music so I was surprised the contestants didn't pick Christian songs for their individual performances. Didn't bother me in the least. :wave:
 

SweetMagic

Oh Meyla Weyla
Does anyone know why there haven't been more celebrity guest coaches this season? Last year it seemed like there was someone each week, but this year only Dolly Parton so far and it's closing in on the end :shrug:
 

GenerationX

Well-Known Member
Well it was inspirational week and that would be an inspirational song. Inspirational to me is Christian music so I was surprised the contestants didn't pick Christian songs for their individual performances. Didn't bother me in the least. :wave:
Didn't bother me, either (I should have put the :rolleyes: smiley at the end of my post). It's just odd to see a scripted, non-mocking Christian reference on network TV. Then again, last season Chris Sligh did sneak a dc Talk song in one week, which was cool ...
 

SpongeScott

Well-Known Member
What was even more surprising was the opening number - an unabashedly Christian song "Shout to the Lord". How did that get past the censors? Outside of Linus quoting the Gospel of Luke in A Charlie Brown Christmas (which I'm still amazed doesn't come with a viewer discretion warning), this is the most Christian reference I've seen this year on network TV. I'm sure someone has been fired.
Personally, I was pleasantly shocked by this. I love that song and couldn't believe that they were actually singing it.
 

Nicole220

Well-Known Member
Personally, I was pleasantly shocked by this. I love that song and couldn't believe that they were actually singing it.
That was my reaction as well.

I actually didn't see it. I turned it off during Mariah's performance. It was 10 so I figured she was the last one to go. But I found out about the last song today at school. I ran off to youtube to watch it.
 

Erika

Moderator
What I don't get is why the contestants are always told to show who they truly are, but then every time David C. shows who he is, Simon calls him arrogant or some such word. I think that causes David to act a bit more humble the next night in order to show that he's not what Simon thinks he is. :shrug:

I know!! Anyway, if he wants to do that whole rocker persona, cockiness is just part of the package. Simon just wants to hold a monopoly on arrogance, that's all. :lol: I do like David Cook and I also liked Michael- sorry to see him go his week.

Does anyone know why there haven't been more celebrity guest coaches this season? Last year it seemed like there was someone each week, but this year only Dolly Parton so far and it's closing in on the end :shrug:

I heard an interview with Simon, I think...? in which he said they felt they overdid the celebrities last year and that the contestants ended up being overshadowed. :shrug:
 

hcswingfield

Active Member
It might also be that so few of last year's celebrity judges could actually sing any more (Diana Ross :eek:) and they didn't want to subject their viewers to that again this season!
 

GenerationX

Well-Known Member
It might also be that so few of last year's celebrity judges could actually sing any more (Diana Ross :eek:) and they didn't want to subject their viewers to that again this season!
Heh, good point. It was frightening to me during Idol Gives Back that Fergie (!) actually sang better than Ann Wilson. Ann Wilson used to be incredible!

I was watching "Don't Forget the Lyrics" last week, and they had Kevin Cronin from REO Speedwagon on the show. Talk about another good singer who lost their voice. Ack!

Of the folks left, Carly and David A probably have the best voices. David C is the best performer, though, and the cockiness doesn't bother me. I'm still rooting for him.
 

SweetMagic

Oh Meyla Weyla
I know!! Anyway, if he wants to do that whole rocker persona, cockiness is just part of the package. Simon just wants to hold a monopoly on arrogance, that's all. :lol: I do like David Cook and I also liked Michael- sorry to see him go his week.



I heard an interview with Simon, I think...? in which he said they felt they overdid the celebrities last year and that the contestants ended up being overshadowed. :shrug:

Exactly! What he does is part of the image he's trying to convey. That's what rockers do. I see what Simon's talking about, but for me it's a non issue. It's all part of showing the audience who he is and what kind of artist he'll be after Idol is over.

Sorry to hear they've discarded the celebrities though, I always liked that aspect of the show. Oh well. :shrug:
 

TiggerBW

Well-Known Member
Didn't bother me, either (I should have put the :rolleyes: smiley at the end of my post). It's just odd to see a scripted, non-mocking Christian reference on network TV. Then again, last season Chris Sligh did sneak a dc Talk song in one week, which was cool ...

I was thrilled by that! And now he's entered the Christian music market making his first album. yay!

well, you figure so many awful songs, videos, bad words, etc. get on tv nowadays so why not christian. :)
 

TurboCaroline

Is it 5:00 yet?
Original Poster
Exactly! What he does is part of the image he's trying to convey. That's what rockers do. I see what Simon's talking about, but for me it's a non issue. It's all part of showing the audience who he is and what kind of artist he'll be after Idol is over.

Sorry to hear they've discarded the celebrities though, I always liked that aspect of the show. Oh well. :shrug:
http://www.americanidol.com/news/view/?pid=1213

In the Top 11 results show, Ryan Seacrest announced that Mariah Carey, Dolly Parton, Neil Diamond and Andrew Lloyd Webber will each serve as mentors to this season’s finalists on AMERICAN IDOL. Each mentor will help the finalists prepare for their Tuesday night performances and then will take the IDOL stage themselves to perform live on the Wednesday night results show. Specific dates for mentor appearances to be announced.
Mariah Carey, superstar and songwriter, has set April 15 as the in-store date for the most eagerly anticipated album of the year, "E=MC²." The 11th studio album of her career, "E=MC²" is the follow-up to "The Emancipation Of Mimi," Carey’s worldwide 10 million selling No. 1 album, which featured "We Belong Together" (winner of Grammy Awards for Best Female R&B Vocal and Best R&B Song) and "Don’t Forget About Us," Mariah’s 16th and 17th No. 1 career singles respectively. The singles tied one of the most enduring chart records in Billboard Hot 100 history: Elvis Presley’s 17 No. 1s. Carey is now positioned as the only active recording artist in the 48 years of the Hot 100 with the potential to surpass the Beatles’ all-time high of 20 No. 1 hits.
The first single from "E=MC²," "Touch My Body," is already a Top 10 radio hit. The video for "Touch My Body" was directed by feature filmmaker Brett Ratner. Guest producers on "E=MC²" include Jermaine Dupri, C. "Tricky" Stewart, The-Dream, DJ Toomp, Stargate, Will.i.am, Bryan Michael , Nate "Danjahandz" Hills and James Poyser. "E=MC²" is executive-produced by Mariah Carey and Antonio "LA" Reid, Chairman, Island Def Jam Music Group.
Dolly Parton’s new album, "Backwoods Barbie" (Dolly Records), entered the Billboard pop albums chart at No. 17, marking her highest debut ever on that chart, and at No. 2 on both the country and indie album charts. The iconic singer, songwriter, film star and entrepreneur has penned such classic songs as "Jolene," "Coat of Many Colors," and her mega-hit "I Will Always Love You." With 1977's crossover hit "Here You Come Again," Parton successfully erased the line between country and pop music without noticeably altering either her music or her image. In 2006, Parton earned her second Oscar nomination for "Travelin' Thru," which she wrote for the film "Transamerica." She has garnered seven Grammys, 10 CMAs, five ACMs and three AMAs; she is one of only five female artists to win the CMA Entertainer of the Year Award.
Beyond a world tour in support of "Backwoods Barbie," Parton is currently putting finishing touches on the music and lyrics for the upcoming Broadway musical version of "9 to 5." Parton starred in the 1980 film and earned an Oscar nomination for writing the title tune, along with two Grammy Awards.
Neil Diamond is one of the most successful pop music performers in the history of music with more than 125 million records sold worldwide, 15 Top Ten albums and 37 Top Ten singles. His work has been celebrated over the past four decades with 12 Grammy nominations and four Golden Globes. He has also been inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame.
Columbia Records recently announced a May 6 release date for Diamond’s "Home Before Dark," the highly anticipated new album from the legendary singer-songwriter. A compelling collection of honest, passionate songs, "Home Before Dark" finds the iconic artist reuniting with acclaimed producer Rick Rubin. The album follows the Rubin-produced "12 Songs," which entered the Billboard Top 200 at No. 4, Diamond’s highest-charting debut yet. The disc was hailed by Newsweek as "the best work Diamond has done in 30 years." The Grammy-winning, record-breaking performer will kick off a world tour this summer, performing to audiences of all ages and selling-out performances across the globe.
Andrew Lloyd Webber is the composer of "The Likes of Us," "Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat," "Jesus Christ Superstar," "By Jeeves," "Evita," "Variations" and "Tell Me On A Sunday" (later combined as "Song & Dance"), "Cats," "Starlight Express," "The Phantom of the Opera," "Aspects of Love," "Sunset Boulevard," "Whistle Down the Wind," "The Beautiful Game" and "The Woman in White." He composed the film scores of "Gumshoe" and "The Odessa File," and a setting of the Latin Requiem Mass "Requiem." In 2004, he produced a film version of "The Phantom of the Opera," and in 2009 will premiere the sequel to "The Phantom of the Opera," which will be helmed by the award-winning director Jack O’Brien. In 2006, Lloyd Webber won an International Emmy for the hit BBC series "How Do You Solve A Problem Like Maria?" He repeated his success with "Any Dream Will Do," and is currently casting the musical "Oliver!"
Lloyd Webber’s awards include seven Tonys, three Grammys (including Best Contemporary Classical Composition for "Requiem"), seven Oliviers (for achievement in London theatre), a Golden Globe, an Oscar, two International Emmys, the Praemium Imperiale (the highest international distinction for achievement in the arts), the Richard Rodgers Award for Excellence in Musical Theatre and the Kennedy Center Honor. He was knighted by the Queen of England in 1992.

:wave:
 

palmage

Member
Did anyone else think Dolly has been nipped and tucked one too many times?
Although I've always thought she was on the ugly side, but she looked awful to me.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom