American Idol: Season 7!!

Uponastar

Uponastar

Well-Known Member
mpoppins76 said:
I know! And I didn't even care for him at first. Now he's my fave :D
Click to expand...

Gah!
I thought Connor was posting in the AI thread!

:ROFLOL::ROFLOL::ROFLOL:

David C's my fave right now too!

MouseMadness said:
Oh yes, his performances are AWESOME every time. *thumbs*

I wish Brooke had slowed that song down. It's so absolutely heartbreaking, and it sounded like a downright jolly tune there. :lol: *edit: more like this, which I LOVE http://youtube.com/watch?v=tcDBgXbGskc
Click to expand...

Agreed!
She "jollied" that up a bit too much.
 
F

Fantasmic!329

Active Member
Did anyone else think that David Archuleta was HORRIBLE tonight?
He had some very ugly notes in there.

I really liked Kristy's rendition of "Coat of Many Colors."
I thought that Syesha did a really good job, but was more similiar to Whitney's version than Dolly's.
I liked both Jason and Carly's performances, as well.

Side note: I thought Paula looked very nice tonight. I really loved her hair!
 
SpongeScott

SpongeScott

Well-Known Member
Paula needs to SHUT UP. Let Simon talk and say his critique without her shooting off her mouth.

End rant.

Ramiele needs to go, but I think Syesha is done. Doing a Whitney Houston song is like the kiss of death on AI.

David Archuleta and Michael Johns nailed it tonight.

And I still don't like David Cook. :shrug:
 
M

MouseMadness

Well-Known Member
SpongeScott said:
Paula needs to SHUT UP. Let Simon talk and say his critique without her shooting off her mouth.

End rant.

Ramiele needs to go, but I think Syesha is done. Doing a Whitney Houston song is like the kiss of death on AI.

David Archuleta and Michael Johns nailed it tonight.

And I still don't like David Cook. :shrug:
Click to expand...

Ohhhhhhhhhhhh yes he did.
smilie_naughty.gif


:lookaroun

And the girls would spin around and look at me and then start giggling every time he said "sexy" :rolleyes: :ROFLOL:

Their version of a naughty word I guess. :lol: :shrug:
 
nibblesandbits

nibblesandbits

Well-Known Member
Here's my ranking:

Great: David Archuletta, Michael Johns
Good: Carly, David Cook, Kristy (eek! Kristy was good in my book!), Syesha
Iffy: Ramiele, Jason, Brooke

Who do I think is going home? It's going to be a toss up between Ramiele, Jason, Kristy, And Syesha. Taking on a partially Whitney version of that song could have cost her. (Although I hope it's Kristy so that my chances are better in the guessing game! :lookaroun )

Michael and David Archuletta were incredible tonight though. Really enjoyed both of their performances immensely!
 
wdwmomof3

wdwmomof3

Well-Known Member
Here are my top three for tonight, David Archuletta, Michael Johns & Carley. They were all great.

I am thinking that it is time for Jason to go home. :shrug:
 
wdwmomof3

wdwmomof3

Well-Known Member
imagineer boy said:
I'm thinking Rameil will leave. She's just so mediocre.
Click to expand...

Yea, she may leave this week but I think that Jason will be next. I really liked him but he plays so dumb, but in a very sweet way, when they talk to him after he sings and I really haven't liked his songs in a couple of weeks.

Do any of you call in to vote?
 
nibblesandbits

nibblesandbits

Well-Known Member
wdwmomof3 said:
Yea, she may leave this week but I think that Jason will be next. I really liked him but he plays so dumb, but in a very sweet way, when they talk to him after he sings and I really haven't liked his songs in a couple of weeks.

Do any of you call in to vote?
Click to expand...
I called tonight to vote a couple of times for Carly and Michael. I don't want to see either of them go yet and with Carly in the bottom 3 a few weeks ago, I"m not taking any chances.
 
PeoplemoverTTA

PeoplemoverTTA

Well-Known Member
MouseMadness said:
It's so absolutely heartbreaking, and it sounded like a downright jolly tune there.
Click to expand...

She was smiling the whole time too...I wanted to yell out, "Are you listening to the words of your own song?!?" I like Brooke, but she's been shaky the past few weeks.

I liked Jason's performance (I just like him...he's not the best singer, but I like his "vibe." Sounds like a dumb reason, but oh well :)).

I think Ramiele and Syesha are the bottom two (sadly, Jason will probably complete the bottom three). I think Ramiele's going to go.

I agree with Simon...had Syesha stuck to the original Dolly version, which is a bittersweet song, very poignant, she would have faired much better. By practically splitting the song in two, and attempting to re-create the most powerful part of Whitney's version, she blew it. She should have just stuck to the style of the first half. Very strange choice on her part...it was really almost like two different songs.

I also like Carly, but I feel like each week she's been slipping...I also agree with Simon (although he was so rude) about her clothing choice. Basically, what I think he's trying to say is that with her image right now, "America" (ie the teeny boppers who will hit redial for 2 hours after each show and most likely account for most of the votes) will not put her in the finals (or even close, I'm starting to think). She's not going to change, though, and unfortunately I just don't think she'll make it past the middle of the pack.

Oh, and finally Michael Johns shows what he's capable of - that was his best performance by far (he's going to need to put together more than 2 good weeks, though...he's been so forgettable for the most part up until last week).

Oh, and Scott, I don't like David Cook either. By all accounts I should, because he's really talented. One thing I don't like is that I feel he comes across as very cocky, and I don't like it. Sorry to all of you who like him. I just...don't :o
 
Jellyfish

Jellyfish

New Member
We're probably really behind you here in the UK. But the guy with the dreadlocks, (is hot) is an awesome singer! Especially when he sang Hallelujah which is one of my all time fave songs :)
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom