I didn't say that they did not need help. I said it is not the park in the most in need of help.
With the amount of revenue it brings in during food and wine, flower garden, as well as holidays around the world… How couple do just fine for the moment.
We are in a triage situation. And by far, the studios are on life-support. Otherwise we wouldn't be bushing our fourth-quarter numbers with a temporary frozen thing.
But for as long as I've been on these forms, the Epcot fanboys have been screaming that their needs the most help. And frankly I'm tired of it.
As one of said Epcot fanbois, I figure I might jump in here and explain (hopefully without falling into my natural state of rambling manifesto when it comes to this topic) without falling back into my bigger complaint about Epcot.
Let's pretend that the festivals don't exist. No Flower and Garden, no Food and Wine, no Candlelight Processional, etc. Does EPCOT still draw 2nd place in attendance at the parks? I don't know if we can categorically answer that question, but my gut feeling is that it wouldn't.
So, trying to take out my main position just for argument's sake, that the park is a shadow of it's former self, I'd think that it's still a valid argument to be made that they had to fall back to adding festivals and special events that last 120+ days of the year (1/3 of the year) in order to draw visitors in to keep it's attendance numbers even semi in check. If those festivals dropped away, or a very similar set of festivals were implemented at the other parks, I'd bet that those parks very well might start beating out Epcot.
Take DHS for example. What if they took a couple of the already successful things they've been doing and extended them. Star Wars Weekends becomes bigger, there are more temporary changes to the park added to blend the theme in more, and the event ran weekdays as well. Then in the fall, they went with the successful Villians event and made a 50+ day long "Halloween / Villians" makeover. I'd bet that with the expansion of these two events, DHS would easily rival Epcot for attendance.
That, IMO is because the park was stale/broken enough that they had to add these extra events to keep the attendance from plummeting. Going back a little ways to 2006 (because I'm lazy and that was easy to dig back to) to look at attendance growth, Epcot has grown 7.69%, DHS by 10.98%, MK by 11.9%, DAK by 14.6%, USF by 16.6% and IoA by 52.8%.
And that is trying to find one angle in without getting into the difference in the quality of today's park vs. EPCOT in it's heyday. We, as (mostly) adult forum goers, still can enjoy Epcot because it's the place where adults can go and eat/drink/stroll. World Showcase still is mostly in tact, and that is the main draw of the park. The other 1/2 of the park is almost an afterthought. If they closed Future World, there might be some moaning on the loss of a couple of rides, but most folks would not care for much more than Soarin' or Test Track (while I'd cry about Living with the Land and SSE going away). I still enjoy DHS because there are some really fun rides there. I can enjoy DAK because of the level of commitment to theme and the animals. At Epcot, well, I like drinking at the Biergarten...
And with that, I've noticed that attempting to stay away from a rambling manifesto has failed miserably, so I'll quit now.