Star Wars: The Acolyte

[MisterPenguin]

It's so weird... where are all the passionate die-hard fans of *The Acolyte* who can't stop thinking about it? We're on the board, and no one is saying much about it. You'd expect more discussion and excitement? Are fans just staying quiet for some reason? Let's hear your thoughts!

I’m ready to see some passionate fans of the show breaking down every moment.

1. This isn't the Spoiler thread.

2. You've been doing a good job keeping this thread being about everything but The Acolyte. [Not saying others aren't also guilty.]

So, knock off the faux turn toward good faith discussion with your unclever sarcasm.

 

[MagicMouseFan]

1. This isn't the Spoiler thread.

2. You've been doing a good job keeping this thread being about everything but The Acolyte. [Not saying others aren't also guilty.]

So, knock off the faux turn toward good faith discussion with your unclever sarcasm.

You think I control the narrative on this board? I speak with passion about things that interest me, and we've had many passionate conversations here. If you feel The Acolyte isn't being discussed enough, it's up to you to bring that passion and create the conversation about the show. Instead of accusing others, why not contribute to the discussion and share your enthusiasm for The Acolyte? Let's see if your passion can spark the kind of dialogue you think is missing.
And.. fair enough, I’ll check out the spoiler board for the in depth discussion on the show.

 

[MisterPenguin]

You think I control the narrative on this board? I speak with passion about things that interest me, and we've had many passionate conversations here. If you feel The Acolyte isn't being discussed enough, it's up to you to bring that passion and create the conversation about the show. Instead of accusing others, why not contribute to the discussion and share your enthusiasm for *The Acolyte*? Let's see if your passion can spark the kind of dialogue you think is missing.

Still not buying it.

I typed passionately.

 

[MagicMouseFan]

Still not buying it.

I typed passionately.

yeah… I see that. Perhaps Ep. 3 will have a big talking point everyone will discuss.

 

[Sirwalterraleigh]

You forget about the 2016 Ghostbusters movie that was completely eviscerated by its fandom.

Not really… quickly forgotten

Not Star Wars

Ask around about phantom menace…make sure you wear Kevlar

 

[Disney Irish]

Not really… quickly forgotten

Not Star Wars

Ask around about phantom menace…make sure you wear Kevlar

Not true, still discussed and complained about by GB fans.

Also you’re the one who brought up that fandom as if it’s some gotcha, and I proved that incorrect because it had the same level of toxicity surrounding it.

 

[Jedijax719]

The Acolyte, at worst, is adequate with clunky dialogue. The story may not be flashy, but it is enough to be somewhat original. It may be meh to some but to others it may be better than that or a little worse than that. Does it feel like it deserves a 28% audience score? Absolutely not. Maybe split down the middle. But a 28% audience score is DEFINITELY agenda driven. There are no two ways about it. Some here will disagree and they have the right to do so. However, it doesn't change the fact that 28% is absurd and has a LOT more to it than a simple 72% didn't like it unless most of those went in already knowing what they were going to think and say about it.

 

[networkpro]

I've had enough of the culture wars slant as there's not much discussion about the actual show. Public ratings are just that... public. Ascribing motivations and taking sides with something that anyone on the internet can participate in is pointless. People for whatever reason make choices and if there's freedom of choice in play its not up to someone else to question or label them as part of some conspiracy. Your passions, values, and worldview are yours and not necessarily shared by others, accept that and move on. This is suppose to be entertainment, not indoctrination.

 

[erasure fan1]

Does it feel like it deserves a 28% audience score? Absolutely not. Maybe split down the middle. But a 28% audience score is DEFINITELY agenda driven

My thought on that is, I'm sure some of it is. But as counter, what do you call a 90+ critic score? I would say the same thing as the 28%. There's no way it deserves a score that high based on what we've seen. When I look at a 28% score, the question I ask is this. Where are the supportes? All of the negative is not just review bombing. There's legitimate criticism in there. But what you don't see is people going out of their way to support it. Maybe they're waiting to see the whole show? That's definitely a possibility. When it's all done I guess we will see.

A lot of the review bombing theory falls apart when you look at other films. Take elemental, it has a 93% tomato score from the fans. That shouldn't be based on what we've been told about the make up of the people review bombing. So the question is, why was that score not lower? From what you read on this site, the film was attacked constantly by the segment who's just "out to get Disney". They miraculously had a change of heart? None of them got the memo to go bomb it? Or was it review padding? If we apply logic to one thing, it then needs to apply to everything.

 

[MagicMouseFan]

The Acolyte, at worst, is adequate with clunky dialogue. The story may not be flashy, but it is enough to be somewhat original. It may be meh to some but to others it may be better than that or a little worse than that. Does it feel like it deserves a 28% audience score? Absolutely not. Maybe split down the middle. But a 28% audience score is DEFINITELY agenda driven. There are no two ways about it. Some here will disagree and they have the right to do so. However, it doesn't change the fact that 28% is absurd and has a LOT more to it than a simple 72% didn't like it unless most of those went in already knowing what they were going to think and say about it.

How do you rank the likability of characters in The Acolyte compared to other Star Wars TV shows like The Mandalorian, The Book of Boba Fett, and Obi-Wan Kenobi? Which characters stand out to you the most, and do you find yourself coming back to watch because of them? Is it too early to form an opinion, or does a show need to lock an audience in after two episodes? With 4.3 million tuning in, what are your thoughts on the show’s ability to retain its audience

 

[MagicMouseFan]

I've had enough of the culture wars slant as there's not much discussion about the actual show. Public ratings are just that... public. Ascribing motivations and taking sides with something that anyone on the internet can participate in is pointless. People for whatever reason make choices and if there's freedom of choice in play its not up to someone else to question or label them as part of some conspiracy. Your passions, values, and worldview are yours and not necessarily shared by others, accept that and move on. This is suppose to be entertainment, not indoctrination.

I completely agree with your point. The focus should be on discussing the actual show and its content, rather than getting caught up in culture wars. Public ratings are just that, public opinions, and everyone is entitled to their own views.

Question:
Considering that 4.3 million people tuned in to watch The Acolyte, what do you think their views are on the story and characters so far? Which aspects of the plot do you think are resonating most with the audience, and are there any characters that you find particularly compelling or well-developed?

 

[MagicMouseFan]

My thought on that is, I'm sure some of it is. But as counter, what do you call a 90+ critic score? I would say the same thing as the 28%. There's no way it deserves a score that high based on what we've seen. When I look at a 28% score, the question I ask is this. Where are the supportes? All of the negative is not just review bombing. There's legitimate criticism in there. But what you don't see is people going out of their way to support it. Maybe they're waiting to see the whole show? That's definitely a possibility. When it's all done I guess we will see.

A lot of the review bombing theory falls apart when you look at other films. Take elemental, it has a 93% tomato score from the fans. That shouldn't be based on what we've been told about the make up of the people review bombing. So the question is, why was that score not lower? From what you read on this site, the film was attacked constantly by the segment who's just "out to get Disney". They miraculously had a change of heart? None of them got the memo to go bomb it? Or was it review padding? If we apply logic to one thing, it then needs to apply to everything.

Maybe it’s closer than we think. The Rotten Tomatoes critic score for The Acolyte is 90%, but when you look at the individual reviews, many of them are 3/5 stars, which translates to 60%. This suggests that while the overall impression is positive, the detailed ratings are more nuanced.

Most fans aren’t as nuanced with their reviews and tend to rate things as either 5 stars or 0 stars, based on their strong feelings about the content. So, the high critic score might not reflect a uniformly enthusiastic response, just as the low audience score might not solely be due to review bombing.
The real question is why many critics are lukewarm on the show with 3/5 ratings and fans, according to Rotten Tomatoes (5000+ views), aren’t enthusiastic… so far. Both critics and fans haven’t seen the full show.

Ultimately, the full picture might only emerge once the entire show is out and we see more balanced feedback from a broader audience.

 

[networkpro]

I completely agree with your point. The focus should be on discussing the actual show and its content, rather than getting caught up in culture wars. Public ratings are just that, public opinions, and everyone is entitled to their own views.

Question:
Considering that 4.3 million people tuned in to watch The Acolyte, what do you think their views are on the story and characters so far? Which aspects of the plot do you think are resonating most with the audience, and are there any characters that you find particularly compelling or well-developed?

I haven't seen enough to "connect the dots" and its not engaging enough to want me to yearn for the softball questions about the state of things that have been tossed up. Its pretty, but not plausible. People in the streets, but doing nothing. No commerce, no stores, no economy. Ships coming and going but why are they doing it ?

 

[MagicMouseFan]

I haven't seen enough to "connect the dots" and its not engaging enough to want me to year for the softball questions about the state of things that have been tossed up. Its pretty, but not plausible. People in the streets, but doing nothing. No commerce, no stores, no economy. Ships coming and going but why are they doing it ?

solid opinion so far

 

[DKampy]

My thought on that is, I'm sure some of it is. But as counter, what do you call a 90+ critic score? I would say the same thing as the 28%. There's no way it deserves a score that high based on what we've seen. When I look at a 28% score, the question I ask is this. Where are the supportes? All of the negative is not just review bombing. There's legitimate criticism in there. But what you don't see is people going out of their way to support it. Maybe they're waiting to see the whole show? That's definitely a possibility. When it's all done I guess we will see.

A lot of the review bombing theory falls apart when you look at other films. Take elemental, it has a 93% tomato score from the fans. That shouldn't be based on what we've been told about the make up of the people review bombing. So the question is, why was that score not lower? From what you read on this site, the film was attacked constantly by the segment who's just "out to get Disney". They miraculously had a change of heart? None of them got the memo to go bomb it? Or was it review padding? If we apply logic to one thing, it then needs to apply to everything.

This why I don’t pay attention to audience scores on TV series….it ‘s pointless…anyone can say anything without watching a single minute…even with films I only check the verified audience score

 

[MagicMouseFan]

This why I don’t pay attention to audience scores on TV series….it ‘s pointless…anyone can say anything without watching a single minute…even with films I only check the verified audience score

I'll be honest, my wife and I do look at the audience score to decide if we want to watch a show. It's easy to pull up and instantly available. That score drives us to the show, but the first episode matters if we continue to watch it. If it doesn't hold our interest, we most likely stop watching unless friends highly recommend it. Just like the general public, we find Rotten Tomatoes audience scores influential. They have, for better or worse, cornered the market for reviews and significantly impact viewership decisions.

 

[Disney Irish]

I'll be honest, my wife and I do look at the audience score to decide if we want to watch a show. It's easy to pull up and instantly available. That score drives us to the show, but the first episode matters if we continue to watch it. If it doesn't hold our interest, we most likely stop watching unless friends highly recommend it. Just like the general public, we find Rotten Tomatoes audience scores influential. They have, for better or worse, cornered the market for reviews and significantly impact viewership decisions.

If that works for you more power to you. But you can miss out on a lot of great content by allowing others to dictate your watch habits based on how some anonymous people on the internet rated things. But hey like I said if that works for you more power to you.

 

[Vicarious Fan]

If that works for you more power to you. But you can miss out on a lot of great content by allowing others to dictate your watch habits based on how some anonymous people on the internet rated things. But hey like I said if that works for you more power to you.

yeah i'm right there with you. I'd prefer to form my own ideas and opinions rather then listen to random reviewers on the internet to make my decisions for me. But I guess it takes all kinds.

 

[Vicarious Fan]

really enjoyed last nights episode.

 

[erasure fan1]

really enjoyed last nights episode.

What did you like about it? I was extremely disappointed. It fell short on just about everything for me. Dialogue was weak, acting was spotty at best, and the whole episode just felt clumsy. I haven't seen a lot of people say they enjoyed it so I'm kind of curious.