S.E.A.
Member
I agree in theory. Pirates is not something that should be overdone, wo knowsd if the movies will stand the test of time.
Star Wars on the other hand has survived that test for 30 years and it's still relevant, even if you despise the last 3 movies. It works, there's a TON of source material to draw from that is varied enough to let the imagination go wild. MGM is about MOVIES. Star Wars isn't merely a flash in the pan. Countless video games, novels & 6 movies exist. It's almost weird to think that there really hasn't been a TRUE Star Wars attraction to this day. Star Tours is a rather weak effort IMHO.
actually, it's not the Pirates movies that are the core of the Pirates craze, it's the whole idealism of the Piratical lifestyle that draws people in. I actually think it would make more sense to build a theme around something that spans different cultures the way Piracy does rather than a group of sci-fi movies that are still fairly new that they aren't as mythical as that of the lives of pirates. It's not the film franchise that makes Pirates more relevant and therefor more deserving of a land than Star Wars, it's the fact that it's based on stories and lore that are part of human history.