wow...tonight was appauling. I thought that everyone did lousy jobs and in a way, it was a waste of my hour.
Katherine was in no way close to Christina, Chris does need to do something a little different, Mandisa's was a mess to me, Kelly was nowhere near good enough, Ace and Lisa were awful, even Tayor wasn't outstanding (but as with others I did understand why he chose the song he did...he didn't want to be seen as the drunk guy at the wedding anymore).
I think of the night Paris and Elliott did the best. I liked Paris singing Work It Out and I didn't think that Elliott's version of the song was bad at all. He actually did something different with it to make it his own.
As to who gets voted off tomorrow, I think it's going to be a crapshoot.
Tonight's badness was all attributed to one thing...and that was song choice. I agree that these people had thousands of songs to choose from and these were the songs they picked? I thought they all picked horrible songs to sing for the 21st century. I agree with Simon (I think) who said that this was an important week and song choice is sort of key because by singing songs of the 21st century, they are essentially showing us, the audience, how well they'd do against others currently in the music field.
I feel let down.
Katherine was in no way close to Christina, Chris does need to do something a little different, Mandisa's was a mess to me, Kelly was nowhere near good enough, Ace and Lisa were awful, even Tayor wasn't outstanding (but as with others I did understand why he chose the song he did...he didn't want to be seen as the drunk guy at the wedding anymore).
I think of the night Paris and Elliott did the best. I liked Paris singing Work It Out and I didn't think that Elliott's version of the song was bad at all. He actually did something different with it to make it his own.
As to who gets voted off tomorrow, I think it's going to be a crapshoot.
Tonight's badness was all attributed to one thing...and that was song choice. I agree that these people had thousands of songs to choose from and these were the songs they picked? I thought they all picked horrible songs to sing for the 21st century. I agree with Simon (I think) who said that this was an important week and song choice is sort of key because by singing songs of the 21st century, they are essentially showing us, the audience, how well they'd do against others currently in the music field.
I feel let down.
