yensidtlaw1969
Well-Known Member
I interpret that post as saying that we shouldn't discuss why the retheme should/shouldn't happen.
I don't interpret it as saying that any comparison between TBA and Splash is off limits. Saying 'Hey, I think the Splash facade did this better and here's why' or "Hey, I think the TBA facade really knocks it out of the park' is very different than saying 'Retheming this ride is the dumbest thing this company has ever done and how dare they ruin the Magic Kingdom and I'm swearing off of Dizneee forever!'
Considering that comparison between TBA and Splash basically devolves every time it occurs (see the last 5 pages of this thread) I'm not sure that's really the case in practice.
If only people were actually engaging with the level of decorum you suggest. But then moderators wouldn't constantly have to be deleting posts and reminding people of the rules, which happens much more frequently in the Tiana's Bayou Adventure threads than pretty much anywhere else on this site.