It's great to hear my opinions posted by someone else. I love American Adventure. it's a great show!
In my opinion, AA is the finest stage show ever created for any theme park by far.
It's also something that would NEVER be created today by WDI. A long, expensive, AA-centric show that depicts the history of our great land.
Nope.
It's much easier to build an empty soundstage/warehouse type building and toss in a 2-3 minute thrill ride with plywood flats (RnRC) or a simulator (MS) or a drive in a convertible (TT).
I never miss AA on a WDW visit. Funny how shows like AA have legs and can go on indefinitely with just a little TLC and updating ...
It still baffles me how so many love Soarin' with its unrealistic film scratches and bare-bones queue and story. We've had Back To the Future for years. Just because you can dangle your feet here doesn't constitute an exciting new attraction. I do however love Goldsmith's score. That pretty much makes it for me. Everything else is rather average, especially if you wind up on one of the ends of the theater. Little things that never would have passed show quality years ago, such as guests casting shadows on the screen, have made it through.
I like Soarin, likely more than you, but I do agree with all your criticisms.
Ultimately, the big thrill is dangling your feet over a dirty print while the scents of orange/pine/sea (which for some 'odd' reason all seem like one scent) are sprayed on you.
Funny how just having things like fog, a wall/curtain between you and the screen, fades between scenes etc ... would have made the attraction better. But why bother? This is the pin lanyard, foamhead buffet, FP-loving crowd.
Midway Mania is sorely lacking in several areas. Some things are done okay and are passable but WDW used to be about straight A's, not C's.
The fact the crowds at TPFKaTD-MGMS are crazy for TSMM is something I blame on the fact there's so little to actually do at that park. And very few 'ride' type attractions. It is in no way worth waiting more than 20-30 minutes for.
~What Will YOU Celebrate? My New SWO/Aquatica AP!~