Do you think that Disney world will reclose its gates due to the rising number of COVID cases in Florida and around the country?

WDW Pro

Well-Known Member
Just curious, but what would have to happen for this to be the case? What is "100% necessary"?

Outside of the government calling for it? One of the big three in the company making the decision. This is the world we live in now.

Germany did a fantastic job at mitigation. We failed.

Unfortunately that's not the way viruses work. You can mitigate, but the virus is still there. The only solutions are herd immunity (might not work if fast mutations), vaccine (might not work if fast mutations), or the virus loses potency over time. Until you reach those points, there's no finish line where you win.
 

chrisvee

Well-Known Member
Germany did a fantastic job at mitigation. We failed.
Exactly. The article goes on to say:

Berner said the study was representative for the state of Saxony, which has a relatively low rate of infection compared with other parts of Germany.

For other states with low infection rates, the study suggests schools could be reopened without causing widespread outbreaks of the virus, he said.


Not too many states in US meet that criterion.
 

havoc315

Well-Known Member
I didn't say anything about wearing masks or distancing guidelines. My response was to the people that want Disney and other businesses to be closed again.

No.. I think people want businesses open *safely.*

That does mean closing some businesses in some locations where it's the only effective way to manage the virus.
It means operating other businesses in other locations with preventive measures.

If Florida was not currently having skyrocketing cases and increasing deaths and filled-up ICUs, that's an entirely different conversation.

The question is --- As applied to Disney specifically, is it a significant danger? And let me say this to everyone -- we don't know.
It's quite possible that the mitigation measures will be enough to prevent Disney being a source of infection directly. (infections at Disney). It's possible that it won't lead to lots of infections indirectly (people getting it on planes, buses and ubers on the way to Disney, hotels and restaurants near Disney, etc). It's also possible that despite Disney's best efforts -- It's just too hard to prevent spread in restaurants with AC systems blowing the virus around, on rides with people screaming, etc.

We don't know. Now, I fully admit I don't know -- but considering the current Florida caseload, I would have thought it wiser to err on the side of caution.
 

havoc315

Well-Known Member
Outside of the government calling for it? One of the big three in the company making the decision. This is the world we live in now.

Unfortunately that's not the way viruses work. You can mitigate, but the virus is still there. The only solutions are herd immunity (might not work if fast mutations), vaccine (might not work if fast mutations), or the virus loses potency over time. Until you reach those points, there's no finish line where you win.

That's. Not. How. It. Works.

We haven't solved AIDs. There is no herd immunity, there are no vaccines and it hasn't lost it's potency.

There is still no finish line of winning with AIDs, as an example.

But there is indeed another very major solution -- Adapting so you can live with it.
Even with a vaccine, most of the vaccines are not expected to be 100% effective. They are actually hoping for around 50% effective.
As with AIDs, they are hoping for therapeutics that make the disease less dangerous.
As with AIDs (which prompted a safe sex revolution), you change behaviors to reduce the prevalence of the disease.
In terms of viral outbreak, when numbers are low, you can safely contain spread with extensive testing and contact tracing. (which is done with HIV too)

You do all those things -- improved therapeutics, preventative behaviors, testing + contact tracing -- Those become a "solution" even without herd immunity, even without a vaccine (or a partially effective vaccine), etc.

There is no finish line here even with a vaccine. Contrary to the perception of some, there isn't going to be a magic day we mark on the calendar where we can rip off our masks and go back to normal.
It's a gradual progression... gradually adapting, following the science, and gradually returning to "normal" though possibly never fully exactly the same normal as we had before. (though I suspect we will get pretty close to that normal in another 6-18 months).
 

havoc315

Well-Known Member
Mayor of Orange County just said in his press conference WDW is one of the safest places to be and what they are doing is outstanding in managing Covid.

Mind you, Orange County has a major economic interest in WDW. So take it with a grain of salt.

I do indeed believe WDW has done an outstanding job putting in safety measures.

But it's ignoring the big danger: How well are all the hotels, restaurants and bar that surround WDW doing? How well are ubers, taxis, buses and airplanes doing that will bring the guests to Disney World?
 

chrisvee

Well-Known Member
Mind you, Orange County has a major economic interest in WDW. So take it with a grain of salt.

I do indeed believe WDW has done an outstanding job putting in safety measures.

But it's ignoring the big danger: How well are all the hotels, restaurants and bar that surround WDW doing? How well are ubers, taxis, buses and airplanes doing that will bring the guests to Disney World?
yes. it‘s the people Disney is drawing to the area during a spike that’s the issue.
 

havoc315

Well-Known Member
He/Florida Department of Health explicitly stated that the theme parks are not showing any issue. They have no indications of that at all.

WDW just opened. You can't going to see an "issue" for at least several weeks. Have other parks shown an issue?
Well... are cases increasing or decreasing in Florida?

Theme parks started re-opening in mid June...

How have cases gone since mid-June?

Capture.PNG


About a 1000% increase since early June. I don't know what degree of the increase is caused by "theme parks." Whether very little, or lots.
But don't tell me there are "no indications" of any issue. There is a big flashing siren of an issue.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom