nibblesandbits
Well-Known Member
Laura...I thought I was the only one! I thought he preformed it well, but didn't know what the crying was about either. I re watched it was well and still didn't get it. :shrug:
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
American Idol: Season 9
- Thread starter TurboCaroline
- Start date
She must have been hormonal...:lol:
Yeah my first thought was "is Kara pregnant?" :lol:
By Casey James??:drevil:
9 for 12. Meh. :lol:
Monty
Brilliant...and Canadian
- In the Parks
- No
Clearly the voting public agreed with me... At least on Toddrick. I can't fathom how they voted to keep Paige or Katie. Katie actually expected to go home. I don't think either Katelyn or Lilly would have lasted much longer anyway, but they deserved to stay more than those two.
k.hunter30
New Member
Well... my favorite is gone. I'm liking this season less and less. Not many really stick out to me. :shrug:
I'm a little shocked by the results last night...Aaron and Katie didn't deserve it. I hope Paige can pick the right song because she has a really good voice...Can she pick a good Rolling Stones song though?? I thought Lily would have made it further but oh well...
No but my FOX HD went black for about half the show, forcing me to watch it in standard definition. :dazzle:
happymom52003
Active Member
Isn't the difference amazing? Now that our eyes are so used to HD, watching non HD is just miserable.
Top 3
Siobhan
Michael
Lee
Bottom 3
Lacey (needs to go)
Katie
Tim
Was it just me or were the judges not as harsh as they usually are?
Siobhan
Michael
Lee
Bottom 3
Lacey (needs to go)
Katie
Tim
Was it just me or were the judges not as harsh as they usually are?
Monty
Brilliant...and Canadian
- In the Parks
- No
The judges seem to lighten up a lot once the guys and gals are together, if I remember correctly.
I thought Paige was in the bottom three in place of Lacey [though Lacey wasn't great either] and Crystal in the top three in place of Lee [though Lee impressed me too - except when he flubbed the words momentarily].
I was surprised that Ellen was the only one to comment on missed/messed-up lyrics and then not as often as it happened. :shrug:
Usually, that's considered a cardinal sin and singers are trounced for it.
Debbie
Well-Known Member
I got to watch last nite after not having a digital converter all of this time. The judges did seem to go easier but I also feel this group is talented unlike some of the previous seasons where many lasted way longer than they should have. I can recall previous seasons where maybe only 5 truly had potential
k.hunter30
New Member
Didn't watch last night, but it was DVR-ed. Anyone stand out as worth watching?
Only Crystal and Siohban....Mike was pretty good...everyone else was not that great....Paige what were you thinking..:brick: Ugh is it that hard to pick a song!!!! I think I made the mistake putting her at #5 in the guessing game...
Only Crystal and Siohban....Mike was pretty good...everyone else was not that great....Paige what were you thinking..:brick: Ugh is it that hard to pick a song!!!! I think I made the mistake putting her at #5 in the guessing game...
Yep. I had her way up top in the game too. I thought she'd do a comeback and kick some butt. Guess she just doesn't care anymore. She was awful!
I also actually thought Lee sounded bad last night too, and was pretty shocked the judges loved that one.
I thought they were too harsh on Mike and Didi.
I'm still a Siobhan fan, but she's not hitting those screams anymore and needs to stop throwing them on the end of every song. Last night was PERFECT until she screamed at the end. She's trying too hard to be another Adam Lambert which just isn't going to happen. He never missed a note.
I would say Tim instead of Katie but he is the one on Vote For The Worst so that may get him some votes...:shrug: