imagineer boy
Well-Known Member
It really doesn't matter who wins tomorrow, they both did terriffic. Either way, they're both going to go on to have very successful careers ( as long as David A's dad doesn't mess things up ).
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
American Idol: Season 7!!
- Thread starter TurboCaroline
- Start date
Computer Magic
Well-Known Member
well you know us Indiana folks...it is not often we get to decide anything that matters :ROFLOL:Oh I see how you are. Waiting for the winner to declare your favorite?
nibblesandbits
Well-Known Member
Now this I agree with...
Nicole220
Well-Known Member
In the words of my dad: "This guy is so talented it's not even funny." (talking about Cook)
The first round was great...absoultely amazing. I can't pick a winner.
The second round was just okay...I gave it to Cook because I loved his song, didn't like little David's song and I didn't like his vocals as much.
I loved Cook's final song...and him crying at the end...*melts* Simon did have a great point about choosing a song he had already done, though. And little David was also great.
I thought the judges were a bit rough on Cook and too easy on little David.
Both have great vocals, but Cook is a total package. He can perform, he's versatile, and he's unpredictable. He's going to become a star. I love him.
Having said all that, I think little David is going to win...which is fine with me.
The first round was great...absoultely amazing. I can't pick a winner.
The second round was just okay...I gave it to Cook because I loved his song, didn't like little David's song and I didn't like his vocals as much.
I loved Cook's final song...and him crying at the end...*melts* Simon did have a great point about choosing a song he had already done, though. And little David was also great.
I thought the judges were a bit rough on Cook and too easy on little David.
Both have great vocals, but Cook is a total package. He can perform, he's versatile, and he's unpredictable. He's going to become a star. I love him.
Having said all that, I think little David is going to win...which is fine with me.
palmage
Member
I think David A's career path is slightly less promising than Taylor Hicks.
He'll go knowhere after Idol.
David C on the other hand has a chance to win an audience from outside the Idol world and make a mainstream career.
Just my opinion I could be wrong.
I agree...
wdwfan100
Active Member
It always seems to me like they try to manipulate the vote this way. It bothers me. I though David A cerainly had songs that fit him better than Cook did. But to hear them talk you would think that Cook had far worse performances. That is simply not the case. I'm pulling for Cook, but think David A will win.
SpongeScott
Well-Known Member
I agree too.
Can you imagine David A trying to headline a concert? I cannot imagine how painful it would be to watch him in the spotlight, trying to carry a crowd by himself.
He will cut his CD, the teeny-boppers will buy it, they'll get a year or two older, he'll be yesterday's news, and he will crash and burn.
wdwmomof3
Well-Known Member
I agree, I am already tired of hearing him, but Cool on the other hand, I could listen to him all day. I am really dreading AI tonight. I am so nervous for David Cook after the comments last night.
SpongeScott
Well-Known Member
Best thing for David Cook tonight is to lose.
imagineer boy
Well-Known Member
Who knows, some people said that Carrie Underwood was the worst winner of AI when she went on to become one of the most successful.
So who knows really, only time will tell.
Fantasmic!329
Active Member
Take it for what it's worth.....DialIdol is claiming that David Cook will be the victor this evening.
Computer Magic
Well-Known Member
less promising then Hick....please
Hick was a product of vote for the worst...Yes David A doesn't have stage presence yet, but better vocals.
Only time will tell.
Nicole220
Well-Known Member
Agreed...MSN's article said it was a knockout. I thought it was very close...
That's what I've been saying. Let him be free.
I'm still amazed at the story about him not even wanting to audition. Can you imagine this season without Cook?
Big thanks to the camera man who told him he was trying out.
Uponastar
Well-Known Member
EDIT