They’re not removing Mermaid a few months after opening a new show. C’mon.
If the garbage Mermaid show, which should have closed forever in 1993, pushes out the excellent Muppets 3D (the second time the show will have pushed out a Muppets show), it’s a mind-boggling indictment of Disney’s judgement.
Disney can do excellent shows - Lion King, Nemo, Indy, etc are all great. But the survival of the profoundly mediocre Mermaid and Beast shows (and, to be fair, the much better Indy show) is incomprehensible. To give context for the attractions age, The day after Mermaid debuted, President George H W Bush vomited on the Japanese Prime Minister. These shows, which barely rise above the level of something you’d see at a local park, have outlived The Great Movie Ride, World of Motion, Horizons, Journey into Imagination, Mr Toad’s Wild Ride and a bunch of other, vastly superior attractions.
Fans understandably focus on Disney’s removal of beloved rides, but equally egregious is letting mediocre attractions fester long beyond any reasonable sell-by date. Mermaid, Beast, the husk of Animation, Mission: Space, the Figment zombie - all should be barely remembered footnotes. Since Animal Kingdom opened, Disney has given very little evidence that they can competently operate a theme park.