Yes, another monorail thread!

PeterAlt

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Which of course is precisely why you bumped this thread "in lieu of the Disney Springs announcement."
On another thread here, I was talking about Disney Springs and DTD, mentioning this thread because of what was discussed about DTD, parking garages, and why or how it could be tied into a future monorail expansion project. I was asked to bump this thread so that the topic could be discussed instead of discussing it there, which would be very much off topic. Now, back to getting those images posted... (sigh)
 

Master Yoda

Pro Star Wars geek.
Premium Member
Wrong again. I didn't say it wasn't coming to that area. It will. Eventually. That's been the plan for DECADES. I hope they do it soon before I'm too to enjoy it! It could be decades more until they actually do it. I think it's between 5 and 10 years away, maybe. Just not part of Disney Springs.
A nuclear power plant, a working city and an international airport were also in the plans at one point as well. Just saying.....
 

Goofyernmost

Well-Known Member
My question would be...why would they expand DTD, build parking structures to accommodate additional need due to the expansion, and then build a monorail to a park? They have been fighting the free parking problem with direct transportation to a park for years, why would they all of a sudden decide that this would be OK to do? They don't want people using DTD as a jump off point, taking up parking spaces that might be used by shoppers? Makes no sense to me at all. Maybe to the resorts but that would be hugely expensive. I don't think it could ever come to be.o_O
 

lazyboy97o

Well-Known Member
My question would be...why would they expand DTD, build parking structures to accommodate additional need due to the expansion, and then build a monorail to a park? They have been fighting the free parking problem with direct transportation to a park for years, why would they all of a sudden decide that this would be OK to do? They don't want people using DTD as a jump off point, taking up parking spaces that might be used by shoppers? Makes no sense to me at all. Maybe to the resorts but that would be hugely expensive. I don't think it could ever come to be.o_O
That one's easy to handle, charge for parking.
 

Goofyernmost

Well-Known Member
That one's easy to handle, charge for parking.
On the surface yes, but when you ask people to pay to park in a place that only offers retail (basically) establishments you encounter a whole lot of people that will not go there. The retailers would not pay the kind of rent that I'm sure they pay, when the number of shoppers go to the free mall down the road. It is acceptable to charge for parking for an entertainment venue, but not for a retail venue. If charging for parking were doable, they would have done it years ago, even without the parking structure.
 

PeterAlt

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
The first set of images are models, renderings, and plans for the LBV/DTD area and were made before anything was ever built there. They clearly intended to build a monorail line and a people mover system there.

2012-07-24%2019.24.34.jpg


2012-07-24%2019.25.59.jpg


IMG_0285.JPG


Here's the old plans superimposed over a recent satellite image of the area..

2012-07-24%2019.22.20.jpg


Now, the EPCOT images! First up is an EPCOT blue print. It's an early blue print, as you can see some attraction names are different. Notice the schematics for the monorail route. Notice the line that spurs off to the east and onwards towards DTD...
2012-10-05%2002.07.40.jpg


This rendering of Horizons clearly shows the DTD monorail line just north of it, between Universe of Energy...
2009-05-13%2005.13.24.jpg


In this photo of EPCOT, taken during the 80's, you can clearly see the DTD monorail line footer behind Horizons...
2012-10-13%2022.18.50.png


Next up is a recent satellite image showing where exactly the buried monorail footer behind Mission: Space is...
2012-10-05%2003.23.32.jpg


Next are a bunch of EPCOT Center construction photos showing clearly the buried monorail infrastructure for the DTD route...
2012-10-05%2001.25.08.jpg


2012-10-05%2001.35.58.jpg


2012-10-05%2001.48.07.jpg


Next is a photo taken by a cast member of a map from the 90's showing the planned DHS route...
2012-10-05%2003.09.36.jpg
 

Master Yoda

Pro Star Wars geek.
Premium Member
The first set of images are models, renderings, and plans for the LBV/DTD area and were made before anything was ever built there. They clearly intended to build a monorail line and a people mover system there.

Here is a picture of Walt in front of the city that was supposed to be built in WDW. I guess we should expect them to start building that any day now? After all, it was planed.

epcot-1.jpg
 

lazyboy97o

Well-Known Member
On the surface yes, but when you ask people to pay to park in a place that only offers retail (basically) establishments you encounter a whole lot of people that will not go there. The retailers would not pay the kind of rent that I'm sure they pay, when the number of shoppers go to the free mall down the road. It is acceptable to charge for parking for an entertainment venue, but not for a retail venue. If charging for parking were doable, they would have done it years ago, even without the parking structure.
When was the last time you parked in a structure for free? There are different expectations for surface parking and structure parking. There are also other lifestyle centers, including Downtown Disney Anaheim, which charge for parking. Add in the option of utilizing any of various tiered or validation schemes and it could easily be done. It would also mean that direct transportation to the parks could be reinstated. Especially when the parks close earlier, buses going straight to Disney Springs would help divert more on-site guests.
 

RedDad

Smitty Werben JagerManJensen
I may just be losing my sight in my old age, but I don't see much in those Epcot construction photos that indicates "buried infrastructure" for a DTD route? Maybe one footing? They obviously initially planned on a route to that area, and it may have made sense to install one or two of the additional footings at the time, but depending on when the DTD route was cancelled I doubt they poured more than that.

I would love for a monorail expansion to happen, but I don't see the money ever working out...
 

Goofyernmost

Well-Known Member
That's an unfair comparison. We all know that those plans died Walt Disney died.
So did the expanded monorail. Reality is sometimes a cruel thing and alters plans of the mighty. That concept has been off the boards for a couple of decades, it is not going to be resurrected. Sorry, but if I'm wrong I will happily apologize to all.
 

PeterAlt

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
I may just be losing my sight in my old age, but I don't see much in those Epcot construction photos that indicates "buried infrastructure" for a DTD route? Maybe one footing? They obviously initially planned on a route to that area, and it may have made sense to install one or two of the additional footings at the time, but depending on when the DTD route was cancelled I doubt they poured more than that.

I would love for a monorail expansion to happen, but I don't see the money ever working out...
We know about only the footers within the Epcot Center construction zone. I suspect that there might be more in other places but I just don't know. Still researching.
 

PeterAlt

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
So did the expanded monorail. Reality is sometimes a cruel thing and alters plans of the mighty. That concept has been off the boards for a couple of decades, it is not going to be resurrected. Sorry, but if I'm wrong I will happily apologize to all.
Sorry but you're wrong. I've heard from multiple credible sources that it's been on-again off-again on-again off-again. Rumor is that it's on again. That map from the 90's shows it was one again at least once during the 90's.
 

Goofyernmost

Well-Known Member
When was the last time you parked in a structure for free? There are different expectations for surface parking and structure parking. There are also other lifestyle centers, including Downtown Disney Anaheim, which charge for parking. Add in the option of utilizing any of various tiered or validation schemes and it could easily be done. It would also mean that direct transportation to the parks could be reinstated. Especially when the parks close earlier, buses going straight to Disney Springs would help divert more on-site guests.
There is a huge difference between DTD Anaheim and DTD Florida. The main one being that the parking structure in Anaheim is for the parks and DTD. The biggest difference is that they are all together in one spot. One usually doesn't go to one and not the other. In Florida the locations are separated by miles and you go to DTD always specifically and it is to spend money other than park admission. You don't have to walk by it on your way back to your car. You have to make a special trip to go there. Mostly at DTD people go to catch a break from the parks and paid admission. To get a little Disney for free. While there they spend money that they can justify because they aren't spending money on park admission. No retailer can afford to charge for parking when there are other options available. If you don't believe that look around and see what happened to downtown districts in any city. In the comparison between the two the prime factor will always be location, location, location.
 

RedDad

Smitty Werben JagerManJensen
Actually, the more I look at the "monorail foundation" in the satellite image, the less convinced I am that it's a footing. If you look at it on Google Earth, it's more than 500 ft away from the current beams. The supports were placed at 110 ft intervals, so it doesn't make sense that they would install that one, and not the other 3 or 4 that would've been required in between it and the Epcot beams. It actually looks more like a lift station or stormwater structure to me...
 

Goofyernmost

Well-Known Member
Sorry but you're wrong. I've heard from multiple credible sources that it's been on-again off-again on-again off-again. Rumor is that it's on again. That map from the 90's shows it was one again at least once during the 90's.
I don't think I am quite ready to admit I'm wrong based on Rumor. When it's there I will believe it.
 

PeterAlt

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
I don't think I am quite ready to admit I'm wrong based on Rumor. When it's there I will believe it.
Let me make clear that I'm not saying this will happen or that Disney has decided to green light it. What I'm saying is that there are plans, buried footers, etc. already in place - just in case they ever decide to go through with it. The new automated systems (which they already said they will upgrade to) reduces cost dramatically (to the point where it's cheaper to operate than buses). Naturally, any frugal company with enough capital would elect to extend it.
 

lazyboy97o

Well-Known Member
There is a huge difference between DTD Anaheim and DTD Florida. The main one being that the parking structure in Anaheim is for the parks and DTD. The biggest difference is that they are all together in one spot. One usually doesn't go to one and not the other. In Florida the locations are separated by miles and you go to DTD always specifically and it is to spend money other than park admission. You don't have to walk by it on your way back to your car. You have to make a special trip to go there. Mostly at DTD people go to catch a break from the parks and paid admission. To get a little Disney for free. While there they spend money that they can justify because they aren't spending money on park admission. No retailer can afford to charge for parking when there are other options available. If you don't believe that look around and see what happened to downtown districts in any city. In the comparison between the two the prime factor will always be location, location, location.
Downtown Disney Anaheim has its own surface lot separate from the Mickey and Friends Parking Structure with its own, different pay scale system paid as one leaves. Both the Americana at Brand and The Grove also charge for parking. It does not have to be $15 when you enter, but a variety of prices based on time and purchases as one leaves. It can easily be structured so that only those there long enough to be avoiding parking fees at the parks would be paying the same or more.
 

Master Yoda

Pro Star Wars geek.
Premium Member
Let me make clear that I'm not saying this will happen or that Disney has decided to green light it. What I'm saying is that there are plans, buried footers, etc. already in place - just in case they ever decide to go through with it. The new automated systems (which they already said they will upgrade to) reduces cost dramatically (to the point where it's cheaper to operate than buses). Naturally, any frugal company with enough capital would elect to extend it.
I'll buy that monorails might be less expensive to operate than buses, the problem is that that cost difference is not enough to justify the Herculean cost it would be to build the thing. Spending a billion to save even $500 million is a bad move no matter which way you look at it.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom