would this upset you?

Master Yoda

Pro Star Wars geek.
Premium Member
People are always looking for ways to "game" the system.

Personally, I think if I were given the choice of free parking at ASM or paying $15/day for parking at the parks, I'd pay for parking. Bus service from All Stars combined with the lost time getting there instead of going direct doesn't seem worth $15 to me.

If she's happy thinking she "got away" with something, I pity her more than anything.
This. ^^^^

On average you would be looking at somewhere between 1-2 hours worth of extra travel round trip. All of that to save $14. One could assume that this family also drives 18 miles out of their way to save 2 cents on a gallon of gas.
 

powlessfamily4

Well-Known Member
I am a little more concerned with the poor example she set for her kids. I find myself more and more disgusted with societies lame excuses for trying to work over any system they find themselves involved in. Cheating is wrong. To attempt to justify it is disgraceful. This parent should not be surprised to find her child cheats on a test later in life. We have a very limited time to set an example for our kids and sadly most parents would rather get one over on the “system” than be the example. Just because you can do, something does not mean you should. She should have reduced her vacation by a day and paid to park. It is no wonder society if flushing itself down a toilet and no one seems to care.
 

powlessfamily4

Well-Known Member
Don't be mad at the woman for gaming the system.

Be mad at the guards who allowed the game to get played.

I work in a building in central Manhattan where, in order to enter the building, you have to show your work ID. If you lose or forget it, they call the floor where you work to confirm you didn't just get fired the day before, then give you a day pass sticker that will get you in the building, but since your ID is magnetized, you're constantly relying on the kindness of your floor's receptionist or other coworkers to get you from your floor's lobby through the security doors to your desk or office. Security isn't that hard to enact in a parking lot, if the guards are of a mind to give a crap. The security guards could ask to see the ID and make sure it's still a valid one. That they would choose not to leads me to believe that either a: they're too lazy to care or b: Disney has decided this isn't a measure worth pursuing or a problem worth solving. As others have said, maybe they hope if you're in the park, the money you're not spending on parking will be spent elsewhere.

I'd be might peeved if I were staying in a resort where parking couldn't be found because of this, though.

And of course, there's always the possibility that the mom who told the OP this story was just B.S.'ing. Some people do like to tell fibs to see if people will swallow their line. My best friend growing up used to enjoy telling people that his uncle was KISS' road manager.


I can’t believe you would suggest its Disney’s fault for “letting” it happen. Are you serious? Shame on Disney for treating us like respectable adults and expecting a person to be decent. I hope this woman is the exception to the rule and not the new trend of normal.
 

slappy magoo

Well-Known Member
I can’t believe you would suggest its Disney’s fault for “letting” it happen. Are you serious? Shame on Disney for treating us like respectable adults and expecting a person to be decent. I hope this woman is the exception to the rule and not the new trend of normal.

There is a system in place that can prevent this sort of thing from happening. The guards, presumably, are paid to do a number of tasks and one of them, presumably, is to prevent WDW from losing money by people who are not staying in a Disney resort, parking in a resort's lot specifically to bypass the fee charged in the theme parks' lots. If someone is able to circumvent the system by waving a years-old pass in a guard's face, then either the guard isn't doing his/her job, or he/she has been instructed not to sweat it, which means this issue seems more important to us than it does for WDW. The only reason this bothers me is that, yes, a WDW vacation is expensive, and I can't help but think that some of the increase in prices, however statistically insignificant to an individual like one of us, is tied to losses they incur elsewhere, be it shoplifting or people complaining a meal was no good after eating more than half of it so they can try to weasel out of paying for it, OR parking in free lots and busing to the parks. Just like if you shoplift from a mall, it doesn't really affect me but for the fact that were they NO shoplifting (or no need to pay insurance for theft or no need for security cameras or extra security forces in the store or at the mall), the price of that item might be a little cheaper for people who ARE honest and who DO pay.

So yeah. It's Disney's fault, or at least the fault of the guard. Huan nature dictates some people are scumbags some of the time (others all the time, and others none of the time) If they did their job, then people would be less inclined to try these sorts of workarounds.
 

cowanfamily

Well-Known Member
There is a system in place that can prevent this sort of thing from happening. The guards, presumably, are paid to do a number of tasks and one of them, presumably, is to prevent WDW from losing money by people who are not staying in a Disney resort, parking in a resort's lot specifically to bypass the fee charged in the theme parks' lots. If someone is able to circumvent the system by waving a years-old pass in a guard's face, then either the guard isn't doing his/her job, or he/she has been instructed not to sweat it, which means this issue seems more important to us than it does for WDW. The only reason this bothers me is that, yes, a WDW vacation is expensive, and I can't help but think that some of the increase in prices, however statistically insignificant to an individual like one of us, is tied to losses they incur elsewhere, be it shoplifting or people complaining a meal was no good after eating more than half of it so they can try to weasel out of paying for it, OR parking in free lots and busing to the parks. Just like if you shoplift from a mall, it doesn't really affect me but for the fact that were they NO shoplifting (or no need to pay insurance for theft or no need for security cameras or extra security forces in the store or at the mall), the price of that item might be a little cheaper for people who ARE honest and who DO pay.

So yeah. It's Disney's fault, or at least the fault of the guard. Huan nature dictates some people are scumbags some of the time (others all the time, and others none of the time) If they did their job, then people would be less inclined to try these sorts of workarounds.


Based off of what your saying, if nobody's not looking, take what you want. This type of thinking has led to the entitlement mindset of everybody. If the cops aren't their to prevent the crime, then it's not a crime. Let's blame the police for every break in because they weren't looking in the right place. It's ok if you sneak into a bar at the age of 16, your fake ID fooled them, drink up honey! Basically what the woman did was steal. If I were to go and steal a $150 coat from Macy's, I would go to jail. But, if the people working don't notice, it's perfectly legal! Slappy, I bet things get pretty crazy in your world!
 

slappy magoo

Well-Known Member
Based off of what your saying, if nobody's not looking, take what you want.
Nope, based on what I'm saying, if you're running a very large business, be prepared for people to try to take advantage of the company somehow, somewhere, and take appropriate steps, especially when you're aware it's happening and how easy it can happen.

If you think I think the woman who supposedly gamed the system was within her rights to do so, you're wrong. People like that make me mad, but I recognize that they exist. I also recognize very simple steps can be put in place to insure they can't game the system the way she supposedly did, as simple as actually giving someone a three-hour ticket for their windshield when they park in a resort's lot, with the provision that they could very well get towed after that three hour period. It's also as simple as a guard getting off his or her *** and looking to see if a card is still valid (and one of the reasons why I think this story is B.S. in the first place - WDW gives you a parking pass to keep on your dash the duration of the trip, so why is this woman supposedly waving her "card" around and getting in? Unless this guard or WDW doesn't really care about parking violators?)
 

wdwmomof3

Well-Known Member
People are always looking for ways to "game" the system.

Personally, I think if I were given the choice of free parking at ASM or paying $15/day for parking at the parks, I'd pay for parking. Bus service from All Stars combined with the lost time getting there instead of going direct doesn't seem worth $15 to me.

If she's happy thinking she "got away" with something, I pity her more than anything.

Exactly!
 

MaxsDad

Well-Known Member
Based off of what your saying, if nobody's not looking, take what you want. This type of thinking has led to the entitlement mindset of everybody. If the cops aren't their to prevent the crime, then it's not a crime. Let's blame the police for every break in because they weren't looking in the right place. It's ok if you sneak into a bar at the age of 16, your fake ID fooled them, drink up honey! Basically what the woman did was steal. If I were to go and steal a $150 coat from Macy's, I would go to jail. But, if the people working don't notice, it's perfectly legal! Slappy, I bet things get pretty crazy in your world!

Not exactly. It would be more like the cops unlocking the door so you don't have to break in. It would be like the bar selling you your ID, knowing it was fake when you used it, and doing nothing about it. Or waving the stolen goods in the face of the Security at Macy's and laughing as you walk by.

But is stealing still stealing if the victim knows it is occurring and allows it? Yes, it is.
 

Polydweller

Well-Known Member
IMHO, I think your friend simply bragged to you and actually didn't get away with that. The resort passes clearly have the dates on them and the guards can see them easily so the chances of pulling that off for an entire week is very low. But it makes a good story and let's her be 'proud' of something whose accuracy you could never check.
 

MKCP 1985

Well-Known Member
There are various ways to avoid paying for parking if one is of a mind to try and is willing to risk being caught or turned away.

I highly doubt those who "get over" care about anyone here's pity. :shrug:

But scamming the guards to park at All Stars on an expired pass is about as lame as it comes. :ROFLOL:
 

devoy1701

Well-Known Member
oh geez.
If I really paid for parking every time I was supposed to, I would have a lot less Disney Souveniers around the house.

The Mouse still got my money. It was either going to be for parking or for souveniers.
 

JillC LI

Well-Known Member
Not exactly. It would be more like the cops unlocking the door so you don't have to break in. It would be like the bar selling you your ID, knowing it was fake when you used it, and doing nothing about it. Or waving the stolen goods in the face of the Security at Macy's and laughing as you walk by.

But is stealing still stealing if the victim knows it is occurring and allows it? Yes, it is.

In my opinion both the woman and the guard were in the wrong - the woman was legally in the wrong and the guard was probably not performing his job duties. But to the point highlighted above, if a victim knows that "stealing" is occurring and allows it, then it is no longer stealing - under the law, it is taking with consent. However, if the guard consented to the taking without his employer's (Disney's) authorization, then in this case, yes, it was equivalent to stealing.
 

Monty

Brilliant...and Canadian
In the Parks
No
The moral part of me isn't for it but the other side of me respects the ingenuity.

Ingenuity would only be the case if she was actually doing it well. Scamming free parking at an All Star resort is probably the least effective method. You're a long way from parks and it's probably costing you much more in time than it could possibly save in parking costs.

There are much more efficient and effective ways to do it, but I won't elaborate since it's still fundamentally wrong.
 

MaxsDad

Well-Known Member
In my opinion both the woman and the guard were in the wrong - the woman was legally in the wrong and the guard was probably not performing his job duties. But to the point highlighted above, if a victim knows that "stealing" is occurring and allows it, then it is no longer stealing - under the law, it is taking with consent. However, if the guard consented to the taking without his employer's (Disney's) authorization, then in this case, yes, it was equivalent to stealing.

Thank you (no sarcasism, really thanks) for the law angle on the question. Good point. I was referring to the moral issue of right and wrong, not modern Man's interpretation of such.
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom