Woman claims to have been beaten in line

Piebald

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
From Cfnews13.com -

Woman Says Disney Bungled Attack Case By Delaying Cop Call
Tuesday, May 29, 2007 10:44:52 PM


* Costly Disney Delay

Aimee Krause said the bruises on her neck came from a brutal attack at the Tea Cup ride at Disney World.

She said another patron quickly escalated a dispute over the lineup for the ride.

“I just kept feeling blows to my legs, my , my head. As the punches were coming, I could feel something tightening around my neck. I could feel the clothes tearing and people screaming," Krause said.

As bad as the attack was, Krause said she's more outraged over the way Disney handled the case. She said Disney security delayed calling Orange County Sheriff's deputies for 40 minutes – a lapse she said dramatically impeded the investigation and made it more difficult for her to press charges.

“At least 120 people were there, because I don't know how many people are held in the teacups, but people had already been seated in their teacups,” Kraise said. “It was only myself as that woman attacked me outside of the teacup ride. There was at least, probably, 80 people in line.”

Disney security spoke with people who saw the attack, but allowed them to leave before deputies arrived. Without sworn statements from witnesses, sheriff's office officials told News 13 they couldn't file charges.

"They're supposed to have the witnesses come down to that security office so that they officers, the true law enforcement officers can interview them there. Had they done that or had the statement, Orange County Sheriff's Department could have made an arrest,” Krause said.

Michelle Mauger, a friend of Krause’s, said she witnessed the attack.

"The entire time we're telling them we want Orange County Sheriff's Office, and they said that they would not bring Orange County Sheriff's Office into the park,” Mauger said.

A Disney spokeswoman said the park doesn't limit law enforcement access, but in this case, didn't see an immediate need to call deputies.

Krause and Mauger said it should be the victim's call – not Disney's – on when deputies are summoned.

“They're not safe. They're not safe because they're not following the protocol that they need to make sure that these people are taken care of,” Mauger said.

According to the sheriff's office, the investigation is still open. Deputies are reviewing information documented by Disney security, and may re-interview witnesses to see if charges are warranted.

http://www.cfnews13.com/News/Local/...ay_may_prevent_charged_in_alleged_attack.html
 

PigletIsMyCat

Well-Known Member
My first instinct is to believe that the victim was, indeed, attacked. I do not doubt the fact that she may have been the victim of an assault on Disney property.

However. I find it hard to believe that CMs and managers would refuse to call in OCSD to assist in a serious beating. I cannot imagine that the CMs would watch the woman getting beaten for a while, then talk to a few witnesses and release everyone if this was a serious beating.

After thinking that, I went to the website link and checked the picture. This woman has a lovely neck, but no bruising that I can see. Now I start to seriously wonder about the severity of the 'attack'.

If she wished to press charges, the CMs probably would have taken her backstage and then called the OCSD anyway so as not to alarm other guests. It also states that witness statements were taken by Disney Security, which should be enough to press charges if desired.

This leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth. I was not there to witness this incident, but I feel that the information I have now doesn't flush with what the victim is claiming happened.
 

mkt

When a paradise is lost go straight to Disney™
Premium Member
Disney doesn't have that much common sense left in the organization :lookaroun
 

Enderikari

Well-Known Member
.... stupid stupid stupid...

Not being there, I really can't make any judgements as to who was being stupid, but in my limited experience, its not a hard call to make, since Orange County is, 9 times out of 10, available already backstage at MK....

Why wouldn't they make that call.... Something is fishy here
 

PigletIsMyCat

Well-Known Member
.... stupid stupid stupid...

Not being there, I really can't make any judgements as to who was being stupid, but in my limited experience, its not a hard call to make, since Orange County is, 9 times out of 10, available already backstage at MK....

Why wouldn't they make that call.... Something is fishy here

That's kind of what I was trying to portray with my long, rambling post. :lol: You said it so much better.

The fact that OCSD is usually around backstage at MK, and the picture of the woman's injuries that is sorely lacking a visible injury, makes me quite suspicious. And I must say, I'm suspicious of the woman's motives. In the article, it says '"The entire time we're telling them we want Orange County Sheriff's Office, and they said that they would not bring Orange County Sheriff's Office into the park,” Mauger said.' If you were being roughed up by a guest, would the first words out of your mouth be 'Call Orange County!!! Call Orange County!!'. Not mine. My first words would be along the lines of 'Get this git off me!' or 'Some assistance would be appreciated'.

Okay. Maybe not exactly that. Maybe a yell for help, or Security. But the victim's friend, instead of trying to stop an unprovoked attack or assiting a CM or Security guard, was calling for Orange County SD. Do you know how many guests know what county WDW is in? Not many. Not many at all.


Fishy. Yes. I agree.

Also, the victim's friend said it should be the victim's decision on whether outside law enforcement should be called onto private property. Is that right? I would think that since Disney is private property, it would be up to their managers and Security officers to decide whether or not to call in the Sheriff's Department. Correct me if I'm wrong, please.
 

Missymoe4

Well-Known Member
Oh my goodness....

Why would anyone ever do something like that? It highly upsets me. Isn't it supposed to be a magical trip...full of fun memories and the such?! Why must people take it to the extreme?! :shrug:
 

PigletIsMyCat

Well-Known Member
Oh my goodness....

Why would anyone ever do something like that? It highly upsets me. Isn't it supposed to be a magical trip...full of fun memories and the such?! Why must people take it to the extreme?! :shrug:

Remember, most guests seem to think that it's only up to the CMs and WDW itself to make the magic. They don't realize that being a courteous, kind, and respectful guest had alot to do with the magic.
 

Missymoe4

Well-Known Member
Ah-ha...indeed you are correct!

I know that it can get a bit hot and crowded there, but still...really makes me wonder these days about people and their actions.

Can't we all just get along?! Oh, and of course enjoy the splendid magic surrounding us while in WDW!!
 

AEfx

Well-Known Member
That's when you whip out your cell phone. If the incident is really as reported, Disney isn't the only one who can call the Orange County cops. If I were ever assaulted on Disney property that would be the first thing I did, before I even got Disney involved.

AEfx
 

DVC Dave

New Member
none of the other guests had cell phones? Not ONE other person stepped in and tried to stop a "beating"? I know i do not have all the info, but something doesn't add up.
 

Rabflmom

Active Member
That's when you whip out your cell phone. If the incident is really as reported, Disney isn't the only one who can call the Orange County cops. If I were ever assaulted on Disney property that would be the first thing I did, before I even got Disney involved.

AEfx


Definitely, the person being assaulted can call in law enforcement no matter whose property they are on. As someone already stated they are already on Disney property anyway. I know when my son escorts people out of the park he works in, depending on the degree of the problem, deputies are sometimes brought in to assist. There are some pretty nasty people that visit Disney who don't seem to feel the magic of the pixie dust and seem to think that rules only apply to others.

Somehow I don't think this was an unprovoked incident. I find it hard to believe that a person just decided to start hitting her. Sound like 2nd graders fighting over being first in line??????? Would love to see the tape of that line to see if maybe she didn't do a little pushing herself.

Did I miss something in the article? Was the person who hit her detained by security ? There is always another side of an incident.
Amazingly, this incident has not been on the local news. This was the first I heard of it. Following last weeks arrests at the MK by deputies, I think we have proof that security does call in the law when necessary. My second thought would be....could security have suggested that maybe both parties would have reason to have the other arrested and were they trying to handle the situation without either party being arrested over a silly incident of grown people fighting over a position in line?
 

dixiegirl

Well-Known Member
Great another thing to add to the growing list of things that have happen the last couple of days

Yes, I have to agree, I have a customer of mine that isn't into the disney thing, can't see spending the much and on and on, she feeds off of things like this......should be fun seeing her saturday..
 

Tenajberry

New Member
What actually happened?

Why would the police feel that they couldn't press charges against the aggressor? :confused: I agree with a statement made earlier. I looked at the slideshow of the "victim" and saw no bruises. :shrug: Has she been to a doctor yet? Medical documentation may help her case. Why isn't her friend being used as a witness? The fact that this "viscous" attack was witnessed should make this more of an open and shut assault case, wouldn't you think? There's definitely more to this story than what this woman is claiming. Why is no mention made of the other woman being taken into custody? :veryconfu

I hate to say it, but this looks like an obvious attempt to extort money out the big WDW. :eek: Anyone else feeling the same?

By the way what started the alledged "assault"? There is no mention to any reason why this attack should have taken place. That's a little odd, too.
 

paul436

Active Member
Also, the victim's friend said it should be the victim's decision on whether outside law enforcement should be called onto private property. Is that right? I would think that since Disney is private property, it would be up to their managers and Security officers to decide whether or not to call in the Sheriff's Department. Correct me if I'm wrong, please.
Any victim of any crime is at liberty to call the local law enforcement agency regardless of where they are. Also, if Disney security took the names, contact information and statements from witnesses, that is enough for local law enforcement to conduct a follow-up investigation if necessary. After all, security can't hold witnesses at the scene if they don't want to stay.
 

toadh63

New Member
Pretty much everyone in Central Florida knows that the Mouse would rather settle for a nice sum rather than go to court.

Looks like some strip mall lawyer with a commercial during Judge Mathis or Tyra is going to be getting themselves 20 or 25K for the cost of filing. Didn't see any injuries - just another local with $$$ in her eyes. Three cheers for Flori-duh!:brick:
 

johnvree

Member
Thank God they scrubbed this from an earlier draft of the article:

"...fountains at nearby Ariel's Grotto ran red with blood after the attack."
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom