That's the crux of the issue right there Disney wants to charge for a high end experience without actually providing one
This was our comment too after our Gay Days visit. We really had a talk about the value of what was offered. Having been three years ago for our youngest daughter's college graduation as compared to Disney's current offerings, we only noticed new offerings in Animal Kingdom. The Tree Of Life awakening was amazing. But THAT was IT.
Epcot future world felt like a badly dated, neglected abandoned mall. It was depressing. I was sitting there having a coffee and feeling annoyed. The communicore cut-through smelled like a sewage back up. Walking into IMAGINATIONS was a shock to see three large portraits greeting us - One has passed (Robin Williams) and the other two - Eric Idle and Rick Moranis - are not really relevant to today's visitor. I mean, I am 50 and I know who they are but can't imagine people younger than me even know who these people are. I remember when Future World inspired me. Now it makes me sad what a shadow of it's former self it has become. We truly enjoyed walking World Showcase at dusk. Appreciated the entertainers and had a nice meal experience at the German Pavilion. Watched Illuminations (a 17 yr old show) and reminisced about how we all missed Tapestry of Nations.
Disney Studios was depressing. We parked hopped later in the day, got to ride Midway Mania (the new third track), rode the 27 year old Great Movie Ride, walked through One Man's Dream and then heard the park announcement at 8:30pm that the park was closing. Urgh. Why did we even bother visiting this park. Again it felt like we were suckers for even walking through the gates.
Thank God for magic kingdom and Animal Kingdom we thought.
Ok. Now we visit Universal after also not visiting for three years. The bottom line was we were wowed by the new offerings and it felt like there were more things to see. Just being able to wander the park stress-free and wait for attractions on the spur of the moment (without having to pre-book 60 days in advance) with wait times of 20 - 30 mins was wonderful. People who pay for Express Pass are few and far between which allows the lines to move. By contrast, the standby lines for Disney were insane due to the fastpass system. I mean, Haunted Mansion rarely had a line until fastpass showed-up.
Our final conclusion was that Disney did not offer the experiences for the money we paid but we felt we got that value at Universal. We typically visited WDW more than twice a year. Now visiting three years apart and not seeing additional WDW offerings was upsetting. I would rather spend the money on a cruise. We just shook our heads,
I understand that it does not matter what we think as long as new people keep showing up. As PT Barnum said, "There is a sucker born every minute"