• The new WDWMAGIC iOS app is here!
    Stay up to date with the latest Disney news, photos, and discussions right from your iPhone. The app is free to download and gives you quick access to news articles, forums, photo galleries, park hours, weather and Lightning Lane pricing. Learn More
  • Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
    Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.

MK Tiana's Bayou Adventure - latest details and construction progress

Status
Not open for further replies.

JoeCamel

Well-Known Member
I'll repost something that a mechanical engineer and experienced AA repairman (who has done substantial maintenance work at both Disney and Universal) said on the matter.

View attachment 810646

He singles out all-electric figures in this case as opposed to traditional hydraulic and pneumatic designs because the electronics don't play as well with extremely damp environments.

Splash/TBA is also more of an extreme case of this than other boat rides. There's a large number of drops kicking up a ton of water into the air throughout the entire ride. POTC by comparison only has drops in the starting cavern areas, and AA's are kept pretty far away from these drops in areas where the flume is less turbulent and less moisture is being kicked up into the air and onto sets. Splash/TBA's drops are not only much closer to many AA' heavy scenes, but the figures are also closer to the the edge of the flume. Most of POTC's figures by comparison are which are pushed further back into the scene.

That said, as I also said, it is pretty apparent that there's an extra layer of incompetent design that went into this ride too. Even the most basic moving figures are breaking down, not just the animatronics. There have also been lighting malfunctions too. So there seems to be a lot of different reasons behind the failures.
Only one reason - improperly done exorcism, once you have gremlins and ghosts you might as well close the doors and walk
 

Kirby86

Well-Known Member
Is that ad art actually real and not edited? That expression is a hell of a choice if it's legit. I'd like to know the story behind whoever drew it and also what sort of approval process it went through (assuming there was any). Because it's hard for me to imagine whoever was responsible isn't trolling.
It's real I've seen it pop up on Facebook ads. She switches out of that outfit because she doesn't want to come off as princess while inviting us.
 

Kirby86

Well-Known Member
TBA reminds me of that meme which is like, "there was a whole wild west shoot out in the microwave, but your food was still frozen inside." Same vibes, honestly.

It honestly just looks and feels unfinished. Which is wild, because the company has actually been talking about this since 2010/2011.

What a squandered opportunity and a bummer.
I still think this was originally just a Disneyland project that got retrofitted to Florida when 2020 happened. All the Imagineers talked about was how Disneyland had a connection to New Orleans in the lead up to Splash closing and how Tiana would fit in perfectly. Magic Kingdom they dropped her into Frontierland and soon her neighbors are going to be Cars.
 

EagleScout610

Owner of a RKF - Resting Kermit Face
Premium Member
I still think this was originally just a Disneyland project that got retrofitted to Florida when 2020 happened. All the Imagineers talked about was how Disneyland had a connection to New Orleans in the lead up to Splash closing and how Tiana would fit in perfectly. Magic Kingdom they dropped her into Frontierland and soon her neighbors are going to be Cars.
Correct.
 

Brer Oswald

Well-Known Member
I rode it for the second time yesterday and I did not enjoy it as much as my first ride. Most of the scenes are pretty boring, and the pacing is really bad. The Tiana and Louis animatronics are really cool in a vacuum, but the overall staging of the attraction does them no favours. The only scene I really like is the first room of the finale.

I still stand by my opinion that this ride would’ve been great if it was the length and scale of Gran Fiesta Tour.
 

Epcot82Guy

Well-Known Member
I rode it for the second time yesterday and I did not enjoy it as much as my first ride. Most of the scenes are pretty boring, and the pacing is really bad. The Tiana and Louis animatronics are really cool in a vacuum, but the overall staging of the attraction does them no favours. The only scene I really like is the first room of the finale.

I still stand by my opinion that this ride would’ve been great if it was the length and scale of Gran Fiesta Tour.

Yes. And floating by the patio of Tiana's Palace (or a similar restaurant concept).

Thinking of newer controversial decisions, I now also can't help but wonder what a Muppet's Splash Mountain ala Western River Expedition could have provided...
 

Brer Panther

Well-Known Member
I recall a friend of mine on Twitter had a pitch for a Muppets retheme of Splash Mountain.

His idea was that Kermit was bringing all the Muppets to visit his swamp, but Gonzo was missing. So the ride was about trying to find him. Eventually, you'd find Gonzo at the top of the lift hill, about to do some crazy stunt.

It wouldn't exactly fit in Frontierland, but hey, neither does Tiana all that much...
 

Kirby86

Well-Known Member
I recall a friend of mine on Twitter had a pitch for a Muppets retheme of Splash Mountain.

His idea was that Kermit was bringing all the Muppets to visit his swamp, but Gonzo was missing. So the ride was about trying to find him. Eventually, you'd find Gonzo at the top of the lift hill, about to do some crazy stunt.

It wouldn't exactly fit in Frontierland, but hey, neither does Tiana all that much...
You can make The Muppets fit Frontier Land out of all the IPs Disney owns they are the most versatile maybe outside of the Fab Five.
 

FettFan

Well-Known Member
I recall a friend of mine on Twitter had a pitch for a Muppets retheme of Splash Mountain.

His idea was that Kermit was bringing all the Muppets to visit his swamp, but Gonzo was missing. So the ride was about trying to find him. Eventually, you'd find Gonzo at the top of the lift hill, about to do some crazy stunt.

It wouldn't exactly fit in Frontierland, but hey, neither does Tiana all that much...

That sounds suspiciously like “The Muppets At Walt Disney World”.

 

Disstevefan1

Well-Known Member
In my opinion, with the stupid decision to fill in river of America and the stupid decision to destroy the Muppets in DHS, by comparison, Tiana is a wonderful, beautiful, glorious change!

Even the destruction of Future World in EPCOT is not so bad by comparison, although I do hate the rusty stuff and I miss the fountain of nations.

Also, the changes to Peter Pan, also totally perfect by comparison. 😉
 

Bocabear

Well-Known Member
In my opinion, with the stupid decision to fill in river of America and the stupid decision to destroy the Muppets in DHS, by comparison, Tiana is a wonderful, beautiful, glorious change!

Even the destruction of Future World in EPCOT is not so bad by comparison, although I do hate the rusty stuff and I miss the fountain of nations.

Also, the changes to Peter Pan, also totally perfect by comparison. 😉
The Peter Pan change is not bad...It is just not really part of the Peter Pan story. The figures look nice... not sure who they are, but they look fine....
 

KDM31091

Well-Known Member
Yes. And floating by the patio of Tiana's Palace (or a similar restaurant concept).

Thinking of newer controversial decisions, I now also can't help but wonder what a Muppet's Splash Mountain ala Western River Expedition could have provided...
I agree, the animatronics look nice but the story falls flat to me. Were it the scope and length of grand fiesta tour, it would be great.
 

EagleScout610

Owner of a RKF - Resting Kermit Face
Premium Member
Something I just thought of for TBA - The choice to not make the finale set at Tiana's Palace makes no sense to me. They talk about it in the queue and everything's "Party at Tiana's place!" Instead we're not at Tianas like said 8 million times, but Tianas restaurant is shoved into the background where Br’er Fox and Br’er Bear were with Br’er Gator.
Screenshot_20240822_191850_YouTube.jpg

Screenshot_20240822_191842_YouTube.jpg
 

Jedi14

Well-Known Member
Something I just thought of for TBA - The choice to not make the finale set at Tiana's Palace makes no sense to me. They talk about it in the queue and everything's "Party at Tiana's place!" Instead we're not at Tianas like said 8 million times, but Tianas restaurant is shoved into the background where Br’er Fox and Br’er Bear were with Br’er Gator.
View attachment 811132
View attachment 811131
The finale is set at Fleur de Bayou, which they say is Tiana and Naveen’s house. That’s what it meant on the chalkboard in the queue and on the radio when it says the party is at her place. Tiana’s Palace is the restaurant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom