Okay, another "insider" in the Disney World Rumors thread about the ride is claiming that the plan for the retheme dates back to 2017, not 2019, and that it was originally just meant for Disneyland but then Splash Mountain merchandise not selling as well as they were hoping made them decide to bring it to Disney World too. And that the main reason they came up with it isn't because of Song of the South being racist or because they want to sell "Instagrammable" food or give people of color representation, but rather because the Brers aren't a profitable franchise. That's it. The fact that Disney previously dubbed The Princess and the Frog a financial failure at the box office apparently doesn't factor into any of this.
I'm just gonna take this with a grain of salt considering it's yet another example of "insiders" contradicting each other, but if there's any truth to this, your precious Mr. Toad is likely gonna be on the chopping block next. After all, Mr. Toad is hardly any more of a profitable franchise than the Brers are.
Heck, ANYTHING could be on the chopping block now. Indiana Jones? Not a franchise that's making Disney money right now, so adios to that. Disney World's Muppet*Vision 3D? The Muppets haven't profitable for years now, so that's likely gonna get bulldozed for more Star Wars crap... and Disney hasn't done anything with A Bug's Life in years, so I guess the Florida version of It's Tough to Be a Bug is getting the axe too. Pinocchio's Daring Journey? If the live action Pinocchio remake isn't a success (or at least doesn't sell enough merchandise), away it goes. How much merchandise does Peter Pan or Roger Rabbit sell? Guess those rides are gonna be replaced too. And lord help you if you're not based on an IP... that rumored Moana overlay Tiki Room is getting more and more likely now, isn't it?
Y'know that quote from Walt Disney about how the tail does not wag the dog? Well, in Iger and Chapek's Disney the tail does indeed wag the dog, and it's going to keep wagging the dog until Disneyland is nothing more than a wasteland of princess, Marvel and Star Wars-themed attractions and gift shops.