Yeah, I read your post a little further down (tough to keep up here sometimes)
But as PO4 pointed out, it is an important part of the equation. Marketing wise, no matter how dumb some WDW vets may think they are, the bands offer some appeal to first timers and may help boost attendance.
Sales wise .... Eh I think they can be more convenient, but as a frugal shopper, no matter KTTW, band or CC I'm still going to be cheap at the end of the day.
This new system greatly benefits me as a local, so u love it selfishly. It didn't cost me a dime. But it has cost them estimated billions.
And since they have been keeping their cards close, no one knows the official numbers yet.