Bringing over from the other thread
@WDW1974 :
I brought up the Newport Bay Club in response to a point about weak maintenance at the WDW resorts. In comparison, I think it's fair to point out that WDW's resort maintenance is far above what DLP has received. WDW has never let one of their operating resorts look so bad on the outside, and they do a solid job updating the rooms at each resort every 5-7 years. Paris is far behind on room refurbishments, and it seems like their maintenance record is even spottier than WDW's.
And to clarify, I understand that DLP's financial history has been troubled (and things are improving now, which is helping to spark new projects), but to the average guest who knows nothing of the resort's history, this still doesn't reflect well on the Disney brand.
In comparison, I'd say WDW's hotels have been maintained with much more care and frequency...but the problems lie with the theme parks (just look at Carousel of Progress, Peter Pan's Flight, Universe of Energy, etc.) and miscellaneous features, such as River Country. Maybe WDW is just too large of an operation and management has gotten complacent? I still feel like they do a decent job with the resorts (especially compared to what I saw at DLP), but as others have pointed out, it seems like they've also given up with the parks. Paris is kind of a mess right now, but at least they're trying - right?