Disney Analyst
Well-Known Member
I think it would be criticised only because of the frog issue. The idea that book-report rides in general are bad is a relatively new one that I don't think exists outside certain hardcore fan circles.
Replacing Splash with a 12 minute book-report of PATF would (in my opinion) be disastrous for them.
Little Mermaid is a cute ride, but it’s not considered a great Disney attraction. Held back by the limitations of a retold story, in a small scale format.
The Disneyland Fantasyland dark rides perfected the concept of taking a movie, and quickly pulling you through moments you know, while still making it feel fresh and adventurous. I think it works in that format well.
But Disney hasn’t done an attraction on the scale of Haunted Mansion, POTC, or Splash, that is a direct retelling of a movie (that I can think of).
(Well you mentioned Splash is a book report, but I concede I had no idea).