Promised an update! Went to HKDL a few days ago and was really impressed with the massive changes in a little over a years time since my first visit.
Thanks for this update! I'm planning a return visit to HKDL in the near future, and I've been itching to read TRs for HKDL for months now. My first and only visit was in 2007, so the changes have really been enormous.
-Does anyone know the actual cost comparisons between the HKDL expansion and New Fantasyland? Really in essence the two have similar make-ups. Instead of Snow White you have Grizzly Gulch Mine Train and Instead of Mermaid you have Mystic Point. Not that I think I dislike or likely will any of those four rides, but I'll give you one guess at which two I think were/will be better.
Regardless of cost, HKDL got by far the better deal with Grizzly Gulch and Mystic Point. Even though I think the Seven Dwarfs Mine Train will be a fun little ride, it can't compare to Grizzly Mountain Runaway Mine Cars... and Mystic Manor simply crushes Mermaid in every way -- something that would true even if Mermaid were wholly original and not just a clone of a walk-on attraction at DCA. And, as much as I think Be Our Guest is nice for what it is, the Explorers Club at Mystic Point also looks fantastic, despite being "only" a counter-service eatery.
-Although I think people may hate the idea of Toy Story miniland, I kind of like it. Like Storybook Circus it's fairly harmless. Although it really, really should have TSMM (same goes for WDS, but that is clearly not happening based on recent posts). I do dislike, not hate mind you, but dislike Toontown. At least RC Racers better captures the teens/young adults crowd who grew up on Toy Story.
I'm one of those people who doesn't think Toy Story Land is an utter waste of space, but I'm still not sure it belongs in a "castle park." To me, Disneyland-type parks are entirely about bringing to life adventures in the past (whether historical or imagined) or the future -- modern-day diversions just seem better suited to a studios or other type of park. And, even though the Toy Story movies are fantasies, they still take place in a contemporary setting. For this reason, I've always been a bit ambivalent about Toontown -- although one could argue that it's set in the '40s or '50s, and thus technically not "modern day."
-I was really excited to ride Mystic Manor, and really did the best to temper my expectations, readying myself to be disappointed. I also never watched a ride-through knowing I was going in a few months, so while I knew enough about it, it was mostly a surprise for me still. I am afraid to admit that I might have watered up just a little bit once I got off the ride... I liked it that much. Stupid Disney Pixie Dust... ... It is one of my top all time favourite Disney rides already. I think that is a very fluid list, but in the moment I felt like it was a contender for number one, and that is saying a lot!
So happy to hear this. To me, the hardest part about waiting has been refraining from watching a ride-through. But I refrained from watching a Radiator Springs Racers ride-through as well, and was very glad I did when I finally made it to DCA. I don't think ride-throughs can capture the essence of a dark ride, where things are happening all around you, rather than an attraction like a roller coaster, which is mostly forward-focused. And I'm confident that MM will be very close to number one on my favorite Disney attraction list as well.
-Love their small world! Other castle parks have their charms, but they seriously need year long refurbs when the clicking of the dolls eyes produce better audio than the speakers. No problem with the Disney character infusions, but I am sure there are purists that hate it. We went on it twice, which I'd never do in one day at any other castle park...
OK, I'll admit to having watched a ride-through (several, actually) of HKDL's small world, which was still being built during my first trip. And although riding it in person might change my mind, from what I've seen in ride-throughs, HKDL's small world looks clearly superior to the other parks'. It has some amazing lighting effects. I know many people are partial to DLP's small world (which I've ridden a number of times), but the reason I don't like it as much as others do is the fact that the design of the sets isn't truly in the Mary Blair vein -- they're not stylized, as in the other small world versions. To see what I mean, just compare the Eiffel Tower in DLP's small world with that in any other version -- DLP's looks like a cartoon depiction of the landmark, rather than one that employs a stylized aesthetic. It does make DLP's small world lusher and more colorful, but also a bit less sophisticated, IMO.
And I completely agree about souvenirs from HKDL vs. those from TDR. I did find some nice things when I was there a few years ago -- like a Shiriki Utundu statuette, a New York City Preservation Society towel, and a Nautilus model made of LEGO-type bricks -- but it's my understanding that many of those unique items have since been discontinued in favor of more Duffy and Shellie Mae merchandise. When I visit HKDL, I'm going to make sure I have plenty of room in my suitcase for the return trip... almost every piece of the Mystic Point merchandise alone looks like it was well conceived with Disney fans in mind.