Yeah, the thing is, those people never were on Disney forums. If someone is 18-30 and they want to ride coasters, then WDW was never for them. It's not like there's been some change in the past 10 years to WDW that has made the parks unappealing to that segment where it was a draw before. WDW has never been a thrill ride destination and has always had that "stigma".
My husband grew up in WDW. His family stayed at the same hotel in St. Pete's every year, so MK was a once-a-year day trip. When Epcot opened, WDW became a 2-day day trip.
I didn't go to WDW for the first time until he took me when I was 23 - in the early fall of 1990. We bought a 4 day pass and used 2 days that trip, and 2 days the following year.
Boy oh boy, was I disappointed. I was accustomed to Canada's Wonderland, which was jam-packed with coasters and thrill rides. In the pre-internet days, I was expecting WDW to be like CW, except bigger, badder, and prettier ... with a castle.
Looking back, that first trip should have been magical! We got day-of ressies at CRT (then called King Stefan's Banquet Hall), and rode all the rides, including the Skyway, 20,000 Leagues, and Mr. Toad.
Instead, I was disappointed. Disney did not meet my expectation for thrills. When we returned the following year, I
started to "get it". We returned to Florida two more times before we had kids, but did not visit WDW.
But once we had kids, I was counting the days until we could take them. Once I was able to see the parks though their eyes, I was hooked. We have now been almost every year since. Hubby and I don't even have to take the boys any more. And for the past two trips, I don't even take Hubby, due to work conflicts. Last trip (and this upcoming one) are with my SIL, who is hooked, and a borrowed niece or nephew from another brother.
I love thrill rides. Correction, I love coasters. I still buy annual passes to Canada's Wonderland; and when we do take the boys, we still go to Uni every other Florida trip. But my heart is in Disney, and I doubt that any amount of high octane additions to USO/IoA will change that. I am Disney's ideal guest. I stay on site; I get the DDP (but only for free, so there!); I rent a car, so I am not a strain on the transportation system; when I do stray up the I-4, it is only for 2 days; I sniff the pixie dust; and I start planning my next trip the day I get home. The current stagnation is all my fault. Blame me.
But not so deep down, there is a part of me that wants WDW to come out with their guns blazing, and really give Uni their come-uppance. C'mon Disney, you can do it. Bring us some big time magic back. You owe me! And you owe Walt and Roy.