I'm a bigger AdvClub fanboi than just about anyone, but I still don't see it surviving, let alone thriving, as a stand-alone venue. Capacity would be too limited, and the humor was dependent on a steady stream of tipsy tourists wandering in with no idea what they were getting into. Babylonia or the Mask Room just aren't as funny with a fanboi-only crowd (observe the final weeks of the Club, where all the jokes became self-referential).
Also, you can't call yourself a "resort" if you don't offer nighttime dancing somewhere on property. And Club 626 doesn't count.