One Sentence Competition - Season 4 Episode 2

Which format of One Sentence Comp do you prefer?

  • The original format (prompts due at 11:59, prompts posted at midnight, reviews following day @ 6pm

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • The current format (prompts due at 8:59, reviews posted @ 11pm, prompt at midnight

    Votes: 12 92.3%

  • Total voters
    13
  • Poll closed .

AceAstro

Well-Known Member
Bonus: The prompt was to add a nighttime experience to the to DCA for Pixar Fest for the young adults. This is something for Pixar Fest, but not a nighttime experience for young adults. Next time please follow the prompt. No points.
C7EF80FC-1520-4E32-8A71-EB65502584B4.jpeg
 

Disneylover152

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
@michmousefan 's The Great Magical Movie Ride
Disneylover152: Riding the movies is such a thing WDI is pushing these days. This does the trick. This would fit really well in Hollywoodland. The only thing is that the prompt called for the entire land to be remodeled, and unless your ride takes up the entire 10.36 acres that is Hollywoodland (in which case great work creating the world’s largest dark ride) it doesn’t follow through the competition. A lot of people have suggested creating a new Great Movie Ride, and I agree. I think it's something Disney would do eventually, but in a new way, like how Mission:Space is the spiritual successor to Mission to Mars. The ride fits thematically and it is realistic. The detail is lacking a little, but the creativity and originality make up for it. Great submission!

DisneyForever: Although it’s lacking a bit of detail, I see where you’re going with this proposal. I think a Great Movie Ride plus 2 could be something DCA needs to make it a good park. For something that used simple technology, this upgrade could really fit in a x2 GMR, and yet we’re still “riding the movies”! I would love to see an exterior of the hills and Hollywood sign. This would be the first GMR “spiritual sequel” that I have seen, and the first one proves to be great. I’m wondering though, would this take up a portion of the land, or the whole entire land? In that case, this attraction would be huge.

Bonus: No bonus?
 

Disneylover152

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
@mharrington ’s Hollywoodland
Disneylover152: A walkthrough Great Movie Ride is an interesting idea. I like it! It could really give people the chance to live their own experience in the movie, and take their time exploring. I dream of walking through my favorite movies. This gives people the way to live the dream. The Great Muppet Movie Ride is another popular idea. I understand why! It’s such a great idea! I’m so disappointed Disney World didn’t build it! I’ve already told you how much I love the Pinocchio idea before, so great job incorporating it to other places. Overall, this is a creative idea with a lot of detail. I could see Disney building a walkthrough Great Movie Ride. The theme is there, and I see the effort you put in! Great job combining previous prompts into this.

DisneyForever: A tour of Disney movie scenes? Wow, that is a first! It also seems like the Great Muppet Movie Ride is popular among these proposals, too bad Disney actually didn’t build this. I would like to see a little bit more detail and how everything would come together. I love how you tied in your DCL Pinocchio project into this, as this is a unique choice. The originality is clearly here, with Pinocchio joining. If only this had a little more detail, I would be able to fully grasp this expansion’s plans.

Bonus: Buzz is a popular character. This party sounds like a great experience!
 

Disneylover152

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
@pixie_princess 's Memory Lane
Disneylover152: The two most popular ideas here are The Great Movie Ride and Mickey shorts. You went with the Mickey short theme, which was not a bad experience. You have the feel of the old Paradise Pier, in a Hollywood themed area. Great idea. Unlike others, yours feels different than Toontown across the world. A Snow White musical would be greatly appreciated, and I love the Mickey Through the Ages dark ride. Also, I love how all these rides and experiences are original! Great ideas for restaurants, I love the Cartoon. The dining experience would be greatly appreciated! The creativity is there, and this is a very original land. I love the theme of Classic Disney. While Disney might not build this, it seems like something Disney would build if Walt Disney was still in charge, and not Bob Chapek. Great job!

DisneyForever: Oh yes, I would love to see Disney create this, it just seems like something they would do. I would be going down memory lane (in more ways than one :p). Since we have a 50s diner at DHS, I would love to see one at DCA, and the Cartoon Cafe seems like it would do exactly that. I don’t know about Oh What a Knight, as if it would be popular or not. Some people might not know what it is (I totally didn’t have to look that up), and just ride it because of the coaster. I would very much ride Mickey Through the Ages, it is just something that would be practical at Disney to have. All in all, I think this is a great proposal, and I would love to see it come to life!

Bonus: Wall-E is so popular! This reminds me of ElecTRONica a little! Seems like a great night time experience!
 

Disneylover152

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
@v_k 's Golden Hollywood
Disneylover152: This is a really great idea! I love the inclusion of Griffith Park. This seems like a Disneyland style addition, and would really bring the locals to this area of the park. It also seems like a Dapper Day hub, if they ever expanded it into DCA. A family coaster would be greatly appreciated in DCA, as Goofy’s Sky School is the only other one. The Great Movie Ride has been a popular choice. Hooray for Hollywood seems like the an amazing Disney show, and the Hyperion Studio with the Goofy Dark ride seems really fun! This is a really original idea for DCA, and it is very creative! The detail is there, and I love the map! It fits thematically too! Nice work!

DisneyForever: Two words, thank you! Griffith Park will finally get the recognition it deserves. I would like to see it more here than in WDW, so great! Hollywood Dash seems like a fun new attraction, boarding a cadillac is cool. And we are back at TGMR! Man, that’s a hot topic ride! As I always have said, this could fit here. I think Hooray for Hollywood would be one of the only shows I would see at the Disneyland Resort, other than Fantasmic. I would really like to see these in-depth, even though I can’t. Overall, this could be a great addition to DCA!

Bonus:
The newest addition to Pixar, this could be a great nighttime spectacular! Painted faces with glow in the dark makeup? Ooh, fun! And who doesn’t love Coco?
 

Disneylover152

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Challenge 2 Results!
There were an absolute ton of quality proposals, making it really hard trying to select and rank the best.

A great idea alone is worth a lot in One Sentence Competition. So is a well-presented proposal. Our top finishers boasted a combo of each, and in such a crowded field many medal-worthy entries are sadly going unrewarded.


Bronze Medal
(1 point)

bK_DzgzmOzdZrMmIrw81Sfa1lb8Fw3Wk8Ck0VYEYRKhlsaUI8EFC2ymobDkAQYoAWIRglVgVq1euMaGihqnRTOWEqPphI5hDYTPaqoC50drFdzE0_W5c8HdnL3PkZZ1Gm-S4pEjl

@D Hindley with Hollywoodland
The project didn’t require a new land, and you proved to us it didn’t! This is a great addition to DCA that is fun and creative. (Reserve @DisneyForever a MaxPass for Beebop Blast)

Silver Medal
(2 points)


qB5CobMYWj6gCXHMaCcyfTPbeYAGIraaeIBfqVyTrv34d1gfxaObcW4zxasJSs7n7da6IHsZa1i-43WGmDPPslsANVJNO-2Q2kZrUQl6NEoxYO_6D0zF9iJXoEvEbPejWBYuoZHN

@pixie_princess with Memory Lane
A land that is beautifully thought-out, thorough, and really brings that something to DCA. This all works out perfectly!


Gold Medal
(3 points)

LARZ91kWS4xM4r_GT757b9LsgSmHdh94wUe2YImKwrRQ1opN857h0PkbyjG6fety3mfHVUFbvoICZ2o5NlL4C4COC1__SfA21Jef_YBkVEcqU1v4bOH3lPSBjxMnKqso0hNVv8vF

@DisneyFan18 with Animation Courtyard
Animation was clearly shown, beautiful. Great detail soared this up to the top!​


Congrats and thanks to everyone who participated! Good luck with Challenge 3, posted later tonight!

Points will be posted soon!
 

pixie_princess

Well-Known Member
@pixie_princess 's Memory Lane
Disneylover152: The two most popular ideas here are The Great Movie Ride and Mickey shorts. You went with the Mickey short theme, which was not a bad experience. You have the feel of the old Paradise Pier, in a Hollywood themed area. Great idea. Unlike others, yours feels different than Toontown across the world. A Snow White musical would be greatly appreciated, and I love the Mickey Through the Ages dark ride. Also, I love how all these rides and experiences are original! Great ideas for restaurants, I love the Cartoon. The dining experience would be greatly appreciated! The creativity is there, and this is a very original land. I love the theme of Classic Disney. While Disney might not build this, it seems like something Disney would build if Walt Disney was still in charge, and not Bob Chapek. Great job!

DisneyForever: Oh yes, I would love to see Disney create this, it just seems like something they would do. I would be going down memory lane (in more ways than one :p). Since we have a 50s diner at DHS, I would love to see one at DCA, and the Cartoon Cafe seems like it would do exactly that. I don’t know about Oh What a Knight, as if it would be popular or not. Some people might not know what it is (I totally didn’t have to look that up), and just ride it because of the coaster. I would very much ride Mickey Through the Ages, it is just something that would be practical at Disney to have. All in all, I think this is a great proposal, and I would love to see it come to life!

Bonus: Wall-E is so popular! This reminds me of ElecTRONica a little! Seems like a great night time experience!

While I agree that Oh What a Knight! Would not be super recognized, I casually point out Splash Mountain and Song of the South, a movie that is banned in the US.
 

DisneyFan18

Well-Known Member
I am hoping you already did but seeing as I was also staying up to see the new prompt I would probably suggest getting so sleep tonight. I don't know what happened but I don't think they will post this late.
I actually began reading something for school in an effort for the prompt to be posted, but I guess I'll be going to sleep soon, I guess that by tomorrow it will be posted, I just hope that I can still be on track with the IPs I can use :)
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom