Seems a bit extreme.
I don't get why so many are so negative about it. Nobody's being denied any access to any attractions, food, merchandise, etc.
The method by which they can get access to them is slightly modified, but still, there's no restriction of anyone who does not choose to stay on property.
I mean, how is this any different than on-property guests have EMH access? Disney is creating value for their on-property guests, which I'm perfectly okay with, considering how expensive it is to stay there. I'm more than willing to pay a little more, to get a little more. This is not a new concept. It's one that is exercised almost everywhere, airlines, hotels, restaurants, car rental, etc.