You not telling the whole story of Brett Favre as Packer. I have been a fan with the Packers since the 1980's. Bob Harlon,Ron Wolf, Mike Holmgren and Brett Favre was responsible for reviving the Packers Franchise.
What you forgot to mention that Brett Favre was turning a out of control Diva before 2008. Brett Favre was holding the Packers Hostage since 2003 with his will I retire or not talk. Brett even had is locker away from rest of teammates. The separate locker from rest of the team came out after Brett was traded. The local media was covering stuff on Brett before it came out once he got traded. I am saying in Wisconsin, there had Brett Favre retirement talk every season 2003 at the time Brett first retired in 2008 by the local media. It was getting tiring from a Packer fan stand point in Wisconsin. Brett's will he retire or not affected Green Bay Packers drafts and is why the Packers drafted Rodgers in 2005 once Aaron felled into the Packers laps. The Packers wanted Brett to decide if he was going to play or not in 2008 for drafting purposes.
If Brett wasn't a Diva, how do you explain he was acting like the GM of the Packers before he first retired? Brett wanted the Packers under Ted Thompson to trade players to get veteran Wide Receivers because he didn't trust the Wide Receivers Ted Thompson drafted. I am talking the same Wide Receivers that Helped the Packers go to the Super Bowl in 2010 and become champions.
One of the Players Brett Favre wanted gone was Aaron Rodgers for getting Wide Receivers that included Randy Moss. I am talking the same Aaron Rodgers that was going to the Super MVP, League MVP and the career leading NFL Passing Rating. That Meant Brett was going to screw the Packers in the future by wanting Rodgers to be traded and that means Packers would be in much worse shape now if Rodgers was traded. Brett was even giving opposing teams outside the Vikings the Packers players when he was a Viking.
The problem with Brett if he was a Packer in 2008, was the Packer's offensive line and Defense. The other issue was Aaron Rodgers was in his final season of his rookie contract after being Brett's back up for 3 years. The defense declined a lot in 2008 compare to 2007. The Offensive line of the Packers wasn't exactly great from 2008 to 2012 and that meant the Packers needed a mobile Quarterback. Brett really hasn't been the mobile since the 1990's because of his age. His arm was still there, but not the mobility. Brett for a time in the 1990's was good for rushing over 150 yards a season and that meant he was mobile despite not being the same league as a Steve Young in the 1990's. Rodgers has the big advantage in mobility compare to a 2008 Brett Favre. Rodgers proved in the Cowboys game in 2007 when he replaced an injured Favre that he was ready to be a starting Quarterback also. The way you look at that 2008 was going to be a Quarterback controversy because Brett still good enough to be a starter, but Rodgers was ready to be a starter also.
I live in Wisconsin and am a Packers fan, too. I agree that Ron Wolf, Mike Holmgren, Bob Harlan, etc helped build the Packers. But the Packers wouldn't be the team they are today without him. Aaron Rodgers learned a lot from sitting behind Favre for 3 years.
I agree that Favre is sometimes arrogant and selfish, but isn't everyone? Favre just tells it like it is, and I respect him for that, even if sometimes he should keep his mouth shut.
Favre wanted Rodgers gone because he didn't want to lose his starting job. Why would any QB want to lose his job? He could've handled the situation better though, I agree. I also agree that Rodgers was the better option for us at the time. I think Favre was the right option up until 2008, I mean he did lead the Packers to the NFC Championship in 2007.
My point is that he is not the devil like people make him out to be. He was just trying to do what was best for him, as anyone should, but his personality comes off as cocky and hot headed. I think he could have handled it better, and so could the Packers organization. But you only ever heard of Favre because nobody knows who Ted Thompson is outside of the Packers community. In the end both sides did what's best for them, they just could have handled the situation better.
Favre was fun to watch and always played with a passion for the game. I will always respect that, and I will always still be a fan.
PS- There's a film out there called
Last Day at Lambeau that is about Favre and his departure from Green Bay. It's very unbiased and I recommend it to any Packers fan. It makes very good points for each side. I'm not sure how anyone would get their hands on it though as it's just a local film.