I may have missed an early post regarding making Imagination vintage 1980's.
But given that TDO, Burbank, whoever, will likely never aggressively market Figment like Duffy, and given that the Pixar movie about the thoughts inside of a girl's head will get tens of millions, if not hundreds of millions in promotions . . . not sure that from a corporate standpoint they could justify not letting the Pixar characters take center stage at Imagination, should they choose that route for a major reboot of the ride.
Well let's just wait and see what happens in 2015 when the film is due to be released. It's easy to make the connection and say that Corporate couldn't justify not doing it but by that logic Dinoland will be replaced by an area rethemed to the Good Dinosaur and the Mexico pavilion will be rethemed to the Day of the Dead film. But given that the film is still some way away and there doesn't seem to be any kind of plan right now for a major overhaul of Imagination, this is all just speculation that, while it might look good on paper, might not ever go anywhere.
Personally I like Figment, but what if you saw Pixar's new film and some of the characters were really awesome. Like what if they had a character that was "Imagination", and was interesting, but they couldn't have both Figment and the new Imagination character in the ride?
I'll wait until I see the film before I make a judgement over whether or not I would like to see a ride based on it. At this moment, I would prefer to see Imagination remain with the theme that is has now but improved to resemble something of the quality of the ride it used to be. For me, it's too early to say with any degree of certainty whether the film would be a good solution.
Obviously, TDO underestimated Figment's appeal as they brought him back. That's shows they do "care" about guests feelings, in so much as they probably got a lot of nasty feedback about the changes. I think after seeing Carsland I'm much more open to new things, and Pixar projects. Before I might have said please keep Figment and the song, but now the possibility of a totally new ride really excites me.
I've always been open to the addition of Pixar attractions, believe it or not, but I don't always think that they're the best or only solution. Like I've said, I would love to see a Ratatouille ride added to World Showcase and I think WALL-E is a character who could be used well in the park but, personally, I would rather see Figment remain at Epcot and used better than he is now rather than see him removed entirely to make way for something Pixar-related. I'm not against Pixar in any way but I would like a balance where the memorable and classicly unique Disney attractions (like Imagination) remain and prosper, not simply because they are unique, but because they really add something to the overall experience of the parks in my opinion.
But even so, you are assuming that Figment has the same potential as Mickey Mouse to be a classic character, all that needs to happen is a big shot somewhere needs to decide to "promote" him. Well, easier said than done, you can't just put Figment dolls everywhere and expect people to buy him. Folks in DLR probably wouldn't as west coast folks have had less exposure in a single ride. To even get a shot to be as popular as Mickey you need decades of "exposure" and dozens, and dozens of cartoons. We know who Mickey is, Figment not so sure.
I really don't think anyone is assuming that and no one has said Figment could ever reach anywhere near the kind of popularity that Mickey enjoys. You say "you can't just put Figment dolls everywhere and expect people to buy him" which is correct but that is not what is meant by saying that they should promote him more. I've suggested ways they could do that here, things like at park opening having Dreamfinder stroll around the entrance plaza with the Figment puppet, interacting with guests. Just to be clear
I know this isn't going to happen, but it would be an easy way of getting those characters out amongst the guests and promoting them.
If they made a Figment movie, and the public responded well, maybe Figment could develop a following.
But from a narrative standpoint, Fig/DF are weak, IMHO. Where does DF live? Figment is magically created, right?, by DF. So, does that mean there aren't anymore Figments? And where does Journey Into Imagination happen? Inside somebody's mind? Pixar is sort of making this film, but without the constraints of relying on DF/Fig.
So, from a storytelling standpoint, Figment/DF's slim backstory basically serve to explain a ride, not to build further interest in themselves as characters.
You say you don't believe that a ride
has to have a film or television franchise behind it but you keep bringing it up. Your opinion about the Pixar potential is fine but put it to one side for a moment because
if it were to happen it would more than likely be quite a few years from now and there has been nothing to suggest it is even remotely on the horizon at present (again, if an insider knows different please correct me). No one here is talking about making Figment into the next big Disney cartoon film star or creating a franchise based around him or Dreamfinder. Looking at your last point there, that is what I want those characters to do, I'm not hoping for "FIGMENT AND DREAMFINDER: THE MOVIE". I don't know if these articles answer your questions regarding the characters' backstory but they do offer a lot of information about them nonetheless.
http://www.mouseplanet.com/9461/Remembering_a_Dreamfinder
http://www.mouseplanet.com/10073/Tony_Baxter_Figment_and_Imagination
I'm not holding my breath about
anything I've suggested in this thread, all I can do is express my opinion that Figment and Dreamfinder could still have a big role to play at Epcot if Disney were so inclined. I'm not saying either should be promoted like Mickey Mouse or Pixar characters but that more could and should be done to at least make people aware of them within Epcot, not anywhere else. Things are what they are and there's nothing I or anyone else can do about that but I do believe there is a fanbase out there for these characters that has the potential to grow and reach more people who aren't aware of them if they were given more exposure. It more than likely won't happen and maybe in ten years Figment will be gone too but I still believe that those characters and the ride they were created alongside have the potential to be a lot more than they currently are.