I've had to UN-Disney-fy my house quite a bit because we have it for sale, but I'll post some updated pictures (basically of the same stuff - just cleaned up a bit) to prove that you can still have just enough Disney around the house to give you happy feelings without it being "in your face". Most people don't even notice my collection because it just blends in with the decor.
I mostly just collect Mickey Mouse and don't get into anything else. Unfortunately, the Disney Store (online) rarely has any decent Mickey stuff anymore like they did years ago so it's been hard to find new things. But here's what I got...
Mickey welcome mat
Door knocker
Picture of my daughter
Mickey Mirror - and you can see my Mickey coat rack in the reflection
Random Mickey frame
Mickey frames and a Mickey
Mickey stuff on the wall
More Mickey frames and a Mickey (talking) lamp
A couple Disney shelves, and I just noticed you can see my Mickey coasters in the basket.