Okay, here’s a rough idea for a set list:
Country Bear Halloween Hoedown
* [Original Opening Song] - Henry, Gomer, and the Five Bear Rugs
* “Midnight in Montgomery” - Wendell and Henry
* “Ghost Story” - Trixie and Gomer
* “I Put a Spell on You” - Romeo McGrowl
* “Yodeling Ghost” - The Sun Bonnets
* “Ghost Riders in the Sky” - The Five Bear Rugs
* “The House is Haunted” - Shaker
* “Sally’s Song” & “Sally’s Song (Reprise) - Teddi Barra and Henry
* “The Devil Went Down to Georgia” - Ernest
* “Blood on the Saddle” - Big Al
* “The Headless Horseman” - Henry, Sammy, Buff, Max, and Melvin
* “Trick or Treat” - Cast (minus Trixie and Ernest)
And just for fun, costume ideas!
* Henry - striped suit jacket with bat bow tie, ala Jack Skellington. His top hat is back, this time with a spiderweb pattern.
* Sammy - back on Henry’s head, popping out of the top hat. Wears a pumpkin hat.
* Melvin- cobwebs in antlers, with a spider dangling down.
* Buff - Frankenstein bolts in neck?
* Max - orange string lights in antlers.
* Gomer - Dracula cape and high collar. Maybe a Phantom of the Opera mask too? Beehive on piano is replaced with a jack-o-lantern.
* The Five Bear Rugs- same as the CBMJ outfits, but with orange/black instead of blue bandanas. Tennessee’s bird has a pumpkin for a head.
* Wendell - white cowboy hat, black vest, and belt with pumpkin buckle.
* Trixie - black silky dress with a black bow & veil. Holding a candle in one hand and a handkerchief in the other.
* Romeo McGrowl - His CBMJ outfit but black with orange accents. His hair is dyed black, and the rose in his hair is replaced with a candied apple that’s gotten all tangled up, and maybe he has candy stuck all over him as well. His guitar is shaped like a skull.
* The Sun Bonnets - dressed with costumes inspired by the Hocus Pocus witches. Not their exact costumes as that’d look tacky.
* Shaker - typical sheet ghost costume, but with one large hole for his entire face. Maybe he’s partnered with a black cat, much like he was in the other seasonal overlays?
* Teddi Barra - witch hat with a purple boa. Her necklace is purple gems, and her swing is wrapped in webbing instead of rose vines.
* Ernest - Black vest, red bow tie, and a black cowboy hat.
* Big Al - Blood red tattered cowboy hat, black vest with red accents, and a trick or treat bucket full of candy instead of his jug.
The theater would be decorated similarly to the Christmas show, with orange string lights added all over. There’d also be lots of cobwebs, jack-o-lanterns, and perhaps some candles as well. I also imagine there could be a gag with the lights going out suddenly to scare everyone, but it was actually just Rufus tripping over a wire.