JustInTime
Well-Known Member
This doesn’t bother me. It’s not a clone of RSR. It’s set in the west. Plus we get villains.
Last edited:
-
Welcome to the WDWMAGIC.COM Forums!
Please take a look around, and feel free to sign up and join the community.
News Cars-Themed Expansion at Magic Kingdom
- Thread starter wdwmagic
- Start date
disney fan 13
Well-Known Member
The fact MK is getting Villians+Cars makes me concerned for the future of TSI. ROA makes the park feel much larger than it is. Purely from an aesthetics perspective it’d be a mistake.
josiah mazelin
Member
Agreed! This makes so much sense. They could even keep the off-roading type of ride especially since that was a big thing in Cars 3
Stripes
Premium Member
The first pitch for Beyond Big Thunder in D23 2022, which I don’t think got much hate, was Encanto and Coco. I hated that idea because the American frontier is not South America and Mexico.
The story of these Cars attractions are clearly taking place in the American frontier and it is a natural fit to expand the borders of Frontierland as we are essentially walking from the frontier of the past to the frontier of the present where we use cars instead of horses to get around.
It’s still the frontier. Just a different era. That’s how I see it. And I can’t think of a better, popular IP, to choose instead.
I’m also so glad we didn’t just get a RSR copy!
The story of these Cars attractions are clearly taking place in the American frontier and it is a natural fit to expand the borders of Frontierland as we are essentially walking from the frontier of the past to the frontier of the present where we use cars instead of horses to get around.
It’s still the frontier. Just a different era. That’s how I see it. And I can’t think of a better, popular IP, to choose instead.
I’m also so glad we didn’t just get a RSR copy!
rct247
Well-Known Member
This was one of the one announcements I wasn't thrilled about. If you told me that this was a transition from Grizzly Peak to Cars Land at DCA, it would have made sense. Even the Carsland from DCA blends with Thunder's location and colors, but this doesn't really capture Frontierland. Instead, I feel like it is trying to repaint the troublesome aspects of the American frontier. Frontierland is becoming what happened to California Adventure - deliberate placemaking and time periods evoking California and its history has been thrown out the window for IPs.
The concept itself seems fun, but again in the wrong location. Even putting it in a North America themed section at Animal Kingdom celebrating nature and the great outdoors fits better!
The concept itself seems fun, but again in the wrong location. Even putting it in a North America themed section at Animal Kingdom celebrating nature and the great outdoors fits better!
socaljoeyb
Active Member
I hope they keep a semblance of the Rivers of America even if it is smaller.
nicb88
Well-Known Member
Just a thought, are we sure they won’t be replacing BTMRR?
‘Take on wild terrain as you race across the landscape climbing mountain trails, dodging geysers and — Mater’s favorite — splashing through mudholes.’
These are all elements of the existing ride, and it’d sure be easier for them to retheme - we’ve seen it happen already to beloved attractions. It’s already been said that TBA divides the land and leaves BTM out on its own…
‘Take on wild terrain as you race across the landscape climbing mountain trails, dodging geysers and — Mater’s favorite — splashing through mudholes.’
These are all elements of the existing ride, and it’d sure be easier for them to retheme - we’ve seen it happen already to beloved attractions. It’s already been said that TBA divides the land and leaves BTM out on its own…
solidyne
Well-Known Member
Better BTM than TSI. Replacing water with concrete: bad.
OSUPhantom
Well-Known Member
Are we certain this is going to be connected to Frontierland? The concept art feels more Rockies/PNW vibes so I wonder if this is going to be its own mini land as opposed to being part of Frontierland
Mike S
Well-Known Member
Dude, they just put a Louisiana Bayou in Frontierland. They don’t care.
McMickeyWorld
Well-Known Member
I’m not convinced by the idea; I would have preferred to see Coco. I guess they just wanted to stick with a USA theme. However, that conceptual art is something beautiful; it reminded me of artwork made for open world video games. I love how whimsical it is. I hope it’s a long attraction so we can see more of those landscapes.
tommyh88
Member
nicb88
Well-Known Member
I guess. I don’t believe that to mean much though, when it’s basically blue sky concept art.
Karakasa
Well-Known Member
Worth noting that depending on WHERE exactly it is, it can be a continuation of the kinda-sorta theme that runs from Liberty Square through to Frontierland. If it's really past Big Thunder Mountain, or west of Tiana's, then it works perfectly - start out in 1700s America, and as you work your way west, you go forward in time before hitting the turn of the 21st century.
Thank you for bringing up this point, it turned me around on the idea. At first I was ambivalent and even a little disappointed but bringing up "eras" made it click into place for me.
Loose Pebble
Member
The art and ride idea sound nice. Just wish this was at Hollywood Studios instead of MK for some thematic integrity.
Although maybe we should just consider ourselves lucky this wasn't brought to Animal Kingdom under the guise of wilderness and focus on American animals...
Although maybe we should just consider ourselves lucky this wasn't brought to Animal Kingdom under the guise of wilderness and focus on American animals...
Disney Analyst
Well-Known Member
So with big thunder in the back… this either has to go in-front of it, or behind it?
So maybe this is indeed just beyond big thunder, before villains land?