Just back from an evening at EPCOT. Overall, I enjoyed myself. I actually decided to renew my pass just to be able to go see it. I generally am good with that decision, with some caveats. For World Celebration Gardens, this is the right idea. But, it feels very budget cut and a little underwhelming. However, I'm happy with the IDEA here. If some new creativity and a proper budget could be added, this is something that pushes EPCOT forward in a way I think both the purists, pixie dusters and day guests would enjoy.
PROS:
-It is very much a tech-hub corporate sitting area. While many lob this as a criticism (which I fully understand), I actually think that works. In 2023, that's probably the best version of this area. The trees are very nice, and it creates little alcoves in the center of the park. That's welcome.
-People were enjoying themselves, myself included. I sat on one of the benches outside Creations with a beer. It was nice just taking in the atmosphere. I'm a convert that the garden approach worked well.
-This could be slowly updated and things swapped out relatively easily to keep it fresh. Much like a good hotel lobby, the bones work. So, the "dressing" could be evolved over time without a full overhaul.
-The music was great. I think they may have fixed the sound, as it didn't seem overly loud at all. And, the continuation through the park made for a very cohesive feel.
-The lights were very, very nice. (But... see below.) People were definitely in the central area enjoying it, especially along the lights.
-As Epcot is the "locals" park for WDW, I think the area has a lot of potential for use. Unlike those corporate parks, APers who just want to be in the park now have a place to relax. It's a lot like Disneyland's benches, and I think that's a good thing.
CONS:
-The balance is way off. I know I probably went in looking for this, but it was noticeable. The "missing 1/4" could actually be solved quite easily with some sort of installation. But, just having random trees with nothing makes no sense. It makes the place feel off.
-Even worse - I fear CommuniCore Hall is going to really make this noticeable. I know it's not finished, but the building looks way too small. It's shorter and less substantial than the original buildings. And, the finishes don't look great already. It feels like something out of the old DTD West Side. It feels cheap. I really hope they do something to plus this. Because, it wreaks of budget cut right now. And, having that plus the nothing trees across from the substantial Creations and Connections looks way off and is definitely noticeable. Plus, when the CommuniCore Hall sign is added, you'll have 3 signs and then a missing one. This is just bad design in a park that has always had the most balanced design/layout of any theme park.
-The lights were definitely broken. The ground lighting was static colors. As were the trees. The only thing changing were the tower lights. That is a huge issue (let alone this soon into its run).
-The area desperately needs kinetic energy, especially without the lights. The central planter makes no sense. The tower lights all focus in on it, and there is nothing. Again, this could be a simple fix. I would vote for either: (1) a kinetic sculpture of the Epcot logo, or (2) a modern/Epcot version of DisneySea's AquaSphere. Either could look great and solve the problem easily.
-The other HUGE miss is the giant planter south of the central garden. What is this thing? It's huge, has random plants and railings and does NOTHING. Now, if they added the sculpture or fountain to the logo, this could easily be the seasonal display. And, that would be fine. Or, this could make for a nice, low fountain. But, as it is, it is a waste of space.
-The World Celebration name really makes no sense.
-The cohesiveness of the entry through World Celebration makes the other additions really stand out. I really wish they would let someone/a team oversee ALL aspects of EPCOT so there is a clear narrative and perspective. That would help a lot.
Overall, I enjoy it. But, I don't know that it accomplishes that much given the time. It's really hard to sit there and not think of what it could have been had this been the original 4 buildings, a version of these gardens (with a fountain) and the entrance we got. But, I think this overall a sign of positive things - if the company will listen.
I'll do a post on Luminous in that thread later as well. (Similar themes will abound.)