Well I don't think anyone was questioning if you were right or not, the issue, for me anyway, is that the cast had not been officially told. Granted, there had been a lot of grumblings around the water cooler that it was happening sooner than later, the right thing to do would be let them have a day to be told, cry it out, and have a moment in peace before they come online and see in message boards and twitter feeds a litany of fanboys jumping and screaming how thrilled they are that the show they all worked hard at for the past five years is shutting its doors for good.
And to be honest, I never understood the hatred of the show. I understand it wasn't a Disney property but neither was Indiana Jones nor Star Wars when they were first introduced into the parks. But it did a lot of things that people complain that Walt Disney World doesn't do anymore. 1. It brought back the feel of live production into what is now a defunct movie/television studio. The production quality between the audio, lighting, and video quality was top rate. 2. When Walt Disney World rolled out the Year of a Million Dreams they were able to convince a park guest that winning a set of mickey ears was fulfilling a life long dream. Here people with the dream of being a pop star had the chance to do it, not just for the 90-seconds they were on stage but during the whole audition process. 3. For quite some time this message board was flooded with messages regarding "Save the Adventurers Club" and this venue became home to lots of the Pleasure Island talent in its early days. I get that the people would have rather see them perform at Downtown Disney but what about supporting the production that is giving these beloved performers the ability to make a living as an actor instead of loudly vocalizing how lousy you think the show is without giving it a real chance.
As a Disney fan I'm excited to see what comes next, hoping its something good. But as an Orlando local,who have gotten to know a lot of the cast members at the attraction and all the hard work that goes into getting these shows up and running my side is with them. And for further proof they were doing good in that facility just search americanidolexperience on twitter and see how much of a difference that attraction made in a wannabe popstar's day.