Honestly, I agree with you - this guy was clearly very biased towards his project, and I really can't blame him on that. I held my tongue instead of disagreeing (which I normally would have done, since I feel Spider-Man is still #1); I too am looking to Harry Potter and the Forbidden Journey, as well as Radiator Springs Racers, to see the true evolution of theme park tech...
Even though ive been on it a million times and its a decade old now Spider-Man is still such a fun ride notice how it doesn't rely entirely on projections (as opposed to most modern disney rides) and has lots of physical set pieces and live special effects.
I can only hope both Star Tours 2 and the Harry Potter e-ticket will be just as fantastic if not moreso.