AI: Season 6

dxwwf3

dxwwf3

Well-Known Member
I thought Phil was the most improved. I wasn't as thrilled with Jordin as the judges were and Melinda & Blake continue to be the best
 
Monty

Monty

Brilliant...and Canadian
In the Parks
No
Gina did well.

Sanjaya doesn't belong on this planet.

Lakisha, Phil and Melinda all sang well, but added nothing of value.

Chris S sounded and looked bored, ad no rhythm and needed to smile a bit.

Haley sang well but was dull.

Blake seemed reasonably ok, but safe.

Jordin was mimicking the original, but did that well and her vocals were spot on.

Chris R seemed comfortable but there was nothing special.

My bottom three Sanjaya, Chris S and Melinda. Going home: Probably Chris S, though it should be Sanjaya.

No-one impressed me like Gina did.
 
Peaches Magee

Peaches Magee

New Member
MontyMon said:
Gina did well.

Sanjaya doesn't belong on this planet.

Lakisha, Phil and Melinda all sang well, but added nothing of value.

Chris S sounded and looked bored, ad no rhythm and needed to smile a bit.

Haley sang well but was dull.

Blake seemed reasonably ok, but safe.

Jordin was mimicking the original, but did that well and her vocals were spot on.

Chris R seemed comfortable but there was nothing special.

My bottom three Sanjaya, Chris S and Melinda. Going home: Probably Chris S, though it should be Sanjaya.

No-one impressed me like Gina did.
Click to expand...

pretty much spot on with that comment!

except I don't see Melinda in the bottom.
Haley should be, she irks me, not sure why
and yes Sanjaya should have been home WEEKS ago!
ehhh... seriously if people dislike the show why do they feel the need to
ruin it for deserving GREAT singers?
I am not doing a hunger strike or anything,
but it is getting ridiculous already. :mad:
 
Monty

Monty

Brilliant...and Canadian
In the Parks
No
Peaches Magee said:
except I don't see Melinda in the bottom.
Click to expand...
Honestly, she has a great voice, but I see no personality, no individuality [exact same paste-on smile and plastic presentation week after week] and she has deviated from the weekly themes regularly to sing songs she prefers rather than stick to the genre of the week. I think she's given far too much leeway because of her "backup singer stepping up" schtick. For me, it's beyond 'getting' old...

She has yet to do anything unique. :shrug:

But then, that's just my opinion and as I've said before... I don't get to vote. :animwink:
 
Computer Magic

Computer Magic

Well-Known Member
MontyMon said:
Honestly, she has a great voice, but I see no personality, no individuality [exact same paste-on smile and plastic presentation week after week] and she has deviated from the weekly themes regularly to sing songs she prefers rather than stick to the genre of the week. I think she's given far too much leeway because of her "backup singer stepping up" schtick. For me, it's beyond 'getting' old...

She has yet to do anything unique. :shrug:

But then, that's just my opinion and as I've said before... I don't get to vote. :animwink:
Click to expand...
Let's see if I can word my thoughts correctly.

Some people are already seasoned and you don't see the improvements each week, case in point Melinda. When you are the front runner early on, it hard to keep impressing people

When someone grows before you eyes, it stands out more, case in point Jordin.

So the frontrunner has a harder time staying ontime and showing improvement.

just my thoughts. :shrug:
 
popsicletrees

popsicletrees

Well-Known Member
I am personally getting tired of Blake. Every week it just seems to be the same. Tonight he did a cover of a cover and the judges praised him for his originality. I don't think he or 311 did a justice to the Cure when they covered "Lovesong." I wasn't impressed with Jordin either. She just seemed bored.

Overall I was most impressed with Phil and Gina.

Oh, Belmont University did a shameless plug by using clips of alumni Melinda throughout her idol journey in order to say they are proud of and want to recognize the accomplishments of all Belmont University graduates.
 
Computer Magic

Computer Magic

Well-Known Member
popsicletrees said:
I am personally getting tired of Blake. Every week it just seems to be the same. Tonight he did a cover of a cover and the judges praised him for his originality. I don't think he or 311 did a justice to the Cure when they covered "Lovesong." I wasn't impressed with Jordin either. She just seemed bored.

Overall I was most impressed with Phil and Gina.

Oh, Belmont University did a shameless plug by using clips of alumni Melinda throughout her idol journey in order to say they are proud of and want to recognize the accomplishments of all Belmont University graduates.
Click to expand...
Gina was the star tonight
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom