Again, the negative arguments leave me dumbfounded.
Sure, I like orginal theme park characters. But, for Disney to turn its back on some of the most popular and profitable characters in the DISNEY canon (notice, Pixar and Disney are one and the same) would just be stupid. It should be a fun and hilarious way to spend a half-hour.
And, the other criticisms I'm reading leave me confused.
Billy Crystal isn't funny! -- He's one of the most popular stand-up comedians in America.
Improv. is all prerehearsed! -- Yeah, sure.
I find it oddly humorous that people would rather have a stagnant show than an animated attraction that always presents a slightly different experience.
I hate pixar! -- Why? As much as it may pain the Disney elite, Pixar has crated the best animated films of the past ten years. In fact, it seems that they have realized what makes animation WORK in the first place. Not annoying characters (Stitch). Not stupid retreads of existing legends (Atlantis, Treasure Planet). But, instead, innovation, imagination, beautiful aesthetics, and strong messages and heart. I consider Toy Story to more Disney (in both tone and spirit) than "Over the Range" or "Chicken Little."
-I miss timekeeper! -- Yeah, well I miss Horizons. Get over it.
-It doesn't fit in Tomorrowland! -- Ever since the '95 revision, Tomorrowland is less about the future, and more about a quirky Buck-rogers-esque vision of what people in the fifties thought the future would be. That includes science fiction movies and B-monster flicks that included a lot of--believe it or not--MONSTERS! Sure, the connection isn't rock solid. But, it works for me. Especially, considering that the Indy Speedway still manages to stick around.
--It's the same as Turtle Talk! Yeah, well Muppets is the same as Philharmagic. Star Tours and Body Wars are the same. Reusing great technology is not wrong. It's smart.
*sigh* I'm done.