Tony the Tigger
Well-Known Member
@Tony the Tigger I need some record store owner advice. My oldest dd wants a record player for Christmas. She wants a blue one and I don’t want to spend an arm and a leg. I saw a Victrola one that is under $50. Are those good enough? She isn’t going to be dj’ing or anything.![]()
You would both do better to spend $100 on a not-blue one, generally speaking.
Not generally speaking, how old is she?
Generally avoid Victrola, Crosley, and Vinyl Styl. These are low budget "suitcase" models all made in the same factory. Not only do they not sound that great (which may not be a big deal) they can have trouble playing the newer 180 gram records (much heavier than most of the records we knew from the 70's and 80's.) The tone arm can skip across the record, and you think the record skips, but it's the turntable.
From experience, we had a lot of people a few years ago coming in with brand new records saying they skipped. We always asked, "What kind of turntable do you have?" And it was always Crosley or the like. Then we'd demo the record on our in-store turntable (which was a used Panasonic from the 80's, nothing fancy) and it would play fine.
Again, if it's for an 8 year old, cool, just have realistic expectations.
If it's for a 12-15 year old, I'd hate to sour them on the record player/vinyl experience by having it do the opposite of what it's supposed to do: sound better and be more fun than an mp3.
To be fair, Crosley has started using parts from another company called Audio Technica on some of their higher end models.
My usual answer is then why not get the Audio Technica brand? The basic model (LP60) is about $100, and it's the only brand we currently stock. We also use it for our in-store demo and listening stations now. It's not "high end" so much as a workhorse that will function well and last.
As far as colors, the newer models just have a stripe across the front - mostly red, white, or black as far as I know. (Maybe green?)
Also, they don't have built-in speakers, so that will kick them up more than $100.
If you do end up going with a $50 one, try very hard to avoid a plastic "needle" (aka "stylus.") They ruin the records. And if you intend to buy any brand new records, they're usually at least $20 or more, so it's a bummer to ruin those with an inexpensive turntable.
Let me know if that brought up any more questions!
ETA: Crosley did an offer a few years ago - if you ordered x number of turntables, they'd give you a free one to use as your in-store listening station. I got the beautiful turquoise blue one! After a few weeks, we had to remove it as our in-store listening station because people thought so many of our used records skipped after listening to them on it!
Last edited: