MK Tiana's Bayou Adventure - latest details and construction progress

[mickEblu]

I don’t understand what you mean. This photo is pretty informative, and most people here liked what they saw:

Because of the amount of tangential discussion it’s generated. Much of it has nothing to do with the painting itself or any sort of construction update; people are rehashing old discontents that were aired ad infinitum months ago.

It’s very simple. The interior shots they shared with us last week are the bare minimum of what we expect. So our expectations are only being met, not surpassed. Well, as much as they can be met for a scene that’s just showing grass, a tree and an old shack. The mural we saw today falls well below our expectations of imagineers and feeds into some of our fears.

 

[MerlinTheGoat]

I DID warn yall a long time ago that some of the co-op backstory would spill over into the exterior as well, not just the queue. I think this is going to continue up until the first drop into the cavern (formerly Slippin Falls).

At least Splash already had some rustic farming equipment, so it wouldn't surprise me if they just leave some of those props alone. I suspect this section of the model for DL is probably a good indication of what the curve atop the mill lift will look like-

It's after the first drop (formerly Slippin Falls) where it's supposed to change and become a musical critter dark ride.

That said, this fence mural I was not expecting. It wasn't included as a part of either DL's model or the CG rendering of WDW's. Though to be fair, Disneyland probably won't receive this mural since they never had the fence to begin with. The fence is actually absent in WDW's render though (I assume it functions as some sort of barrier to hide backstage/mechanical elements and the artists simply didn't think to include it in the render). The mural definitely does not look good regardless.

 

[LittleBuford]

It’s very simple. The interior shots they shared with us last week are the bare minimum of what we expect. So our expectations are being met. Well, as much as they can be met for a scene that’s just showing grass, a tree and an old shack.

At least some posters seemed pleasantly surprised, relieved almost. I just went back and looked at the posts in question to make sure I wasn't misremembering.

The mural we saw today falls well below our expectations of imagineers and feeds into some of our fears.

Yes, and I suppose it's the extent and immediacy of those fears that I'm taken aback by.

 

[mickEblu]

At least some posters seemed pleasantly surprised, relieved almost. I just went back and looked at the posts in question to make sure I wasn't misremembering.


Yes, and I suppose it's the extent and immediacy of those fears that I'm taken aback by.

Well that just shows you that we may not all be as negative as you think if just the smallest reassurance makes one happy.

The new mural in the rustic old mill is pretty egregious though. I don’t trust the people who decided to put that there.

 

[TrainsOfDisney]

Yes, and I suppose it's the extent and immediacy of those fears that I'm taken aback by.

Does either mural give you hope that they are gonna get this right?

 

[LittleBuford]

Well that just shows you that we may not all be as negative as you think if just the smallest reassurance makes one happy.

I was relieved too. What some of you seem not to understand is that this needn't be a binary choice between being for or against the new attraction. I loved Splash Mountain and will miss it terribly, and I am quite nervous about Tiana's Bayou Adventure. At the same time, I'm not sure what there is to gain by assuming it's going to be trash when the updates have been a mixed (and somewhat confusing) bag. It makes more sense in my view to wait for the final product and keep an open mind in the meantime.

 

[LittleBuford]

Does either mural give you hope that they are gonna get this right?

I've come around to the larger mural. It doesn't relate to the period in any real way, but it gives off a fun, festive vibe that I hope is there in the ride itself.

I doubt I'll ever like the mural that was revealed today. It'll probably look less bad in the context of the overall ride, which will have much else to see, but it'll never win me over in isolation.

 

[mickEblu]

I was relieved too. What some of you seem not to understand is that this needn't be a binary choice between being for or against the new attraction. I loved Splash Mountain and will miss it terribly, and I am quite nervous about Tiana's Bayou Adventure. At the same time, I'm not sure what there is to gain by assuming it's going to be trash when the updates have been a mixed (and somewhat confusing) bag. It makes more sense to me to wait and keep and open mind in the meantime.

It’s really simple. We don’t like what we’re seeing or hearing. This is how things work. The extent of the concern is based on how much we don’t like what we’re seeing or hearing. For example so far all I like is the stone work in the exterior queue and can appreciate the greenery on the mountain even if I believe if it’s a little too much and doesn’t quite fit in Frontierland. Keeping an open mind is a more realistic ask if one likes at least 50% or more of what they’re seeing/ hearing. It also depends on the amount of faith one has in the people doing the work.

 

[LittleBuford]

It’s really simple. We don’t like what we’re seeing or hearing. This is how things work. The extent of the concern is based on how much we don’t like what we’re seeing or hearing. For example so far all I like is the stone work in the exterior queue and can appreciate the greenery on the mountain even if I believe if it’s a little too much and doesn’t quite fit in Frontierland. Keeping an open mind is a more realistic ask if one likes at least 50% or more of what they’re seeing/ hearing and the amount of faith one has in the people doing the work.

I hope you're pleasantly surprised in the end.

 

[aladdin2007]

Well that just shows you that we may not all be as negative as you think if just the smallest reassurance makes one happy.

The new mural in the rustic old mill is pretty egregious though. I don’t trust the people who decided to put that there.

starting to feel like a ride through a garbage disposal...really hoping this is for some other placement than what were seeing, but not looking good.

 

[celluloid]

. It makes more sense in my view to wait for the final product and keep an open mind in the meantime.

I think it is fair to keep a balance of the bad with the good. If you just keep saying an open mind, then there is some weird concept where you can only approve and be excited about construction and choices as they are revealed.

It is ok if the latest out of setting mural and further evidence of odd show writing gives less trust in the project.

When concerned about the conceit of the ride, people were told in varying sarcastic tones that it was not the case.

There is continual evidence that it is a large part of the attraction, down to the ride path scenes now.

 

[mickEblu]

starting to feel like a ride through a garbage disposal...really hoping this is for some other placement than what were seeing, but not looking good.

In many ways this is the new Disney. Just throw more Disney IP iconography everywhere and call it theming. Doesn’t display any understanding of establishing a sense of time and place. Tiana spruced up the old rustic mill. I would say this is what happens when you retheme a purpose built attraction into a new ride but in this case retheming Splash into TBA should have been a slam dunk.

If Fantasyland was built today it would look like Pixar Pier.

 

[celluloid]

In many ways this is the new Disney. Just throw more Disney IP iconography everywhere and call it theming. Doesn’t display any understanding of creating a time and place. If Fantasyland was built today it would look like Pixar Pier.

In the industry, this way out is sometimes called associative theming. Toy Story Land and Pixar Pier have a lot of this. There is sort of an attempt with Toy Story Land but ultimately, it is more association than a full-fledged experience.

The phrase I often use with Assocation theming is The Cheesecake Factory. The atmosphere of that place is...kind of, sort of cheesecake, but no one really knows why or how it is themed. It is associated.

I don't think Tiana would be quite this bad, but it is suffering from a lot of the idea and not being too rich.

 

[LittleBuford]

If you just keep saying an open mind, then there is some weird concept where you can only approve and be excited about construction and choices as they are revealed.

If I thought or meant that, I wouldn't have shared my own dislike of the new mural.

 

[TrainsOfDisney]

There is sort of an attempt with Toy Story Land but ultimately, it is more association than a full-fledged experience.

Yes, and compare it directly with bugs land that truly felt like a unique place.

 

[celluloid]

If I thought or meant that, I wouldn't have shared my own dislike of the new mural.

It is strange for one to toss in their own opinion, after saying everyone else should wait when they have critiques.

 

[LittleBuford]

It is strange for one to toss in their own opinion, after saying everyone else should wait when they have critiques.

That isn't what I said. At all.

 

[celluloid]

That isn't what I said. At all.

You have stated that this thread has spun into over negativity. And you then gave your negative take on the mural, but did not like that why it and the further evoking the disliked conceit the attraction has had was spinning. You then said in a post that you think it is helpful to wait, after stating the mural itself will never win you over.

What about this is not what you said. "At All?" All of that is completely wrong from what you stated?

People were told that the ride will not feature the Food co-op backstory, and then a mural of a knife cutting food into gumbo ingredients then a bowl full of gumbo appears along the ride path itself.

Old concerns that were told to be hushed will for sure come back as there is evidence.

 

[Mikomike12]

Please take your whining to this thread.

News - Splash Mountain retheme to Princess and the Frog - Tiana's Bayou Adventure

The original announcement of the Splash Mountain to Princess and the Frog thread is now available in the 'Politics and Social Issues' forum at https://forums.wdwmagic.com/threads/splash-mountain-re-theme-announced.965846/unread In the absence of many specific details on the project and due to...

forums.wdwmagic.com

This thread is for construction updates.

For the love of god people, how many times do people/mods here have to reiterate this thread is for construction. please take your endless gripes to the other thread, I promise you 90% of what your complaining has already been said on atleast a dozen pages past, take it to the other thread I shouldn’t have to skip through 30 pages to find one photo of construction that 5 people talk about while the other 50 complain about something irrelevant

 

[celluloid]

For the love of god people, how many times do people/mods here have to reiterate this thread is for construction. please take your endless gripes to the other thread, I promise you 90% of what your complaining has already been said on atleast a dozen pages past, take it to the other thread I shouldn’t have to skip through 30 pages to find one photo of construction that 5 people talk about while the other 50 complain about something irrelevant

The discussion is on the construction relating to evidence of the attraction's storyline. Thematic elements are being installed that connect this.
If the thread is ONLY and Soley for images of construction, then you have no discussion. The point of a discussion board is to discuss the construction. New mural work was posted today and being discussed.
The mural is what was being discussed as it is a mural of food being prepared to serve.