I love Disney and the atmosphere that you get from staying onsite. So much so that apart from my first two trips to Orlando I have stayed in onsite hotels (from economy to deluxe). That said, I am visiting from the UK and with all the 'perks' that have been taken away and the additional costs for riding attractions (let's face it as much as I am heartbroken about the free FP being replaced with a paid option I will have no choice but to cough up as we are travelling from too far away and visit too few times over the years to spend all day queuing up). We only have a finite budget. So to stretch it out we have opted to rent a villa with a pool for the majority of the holiday (14 nights). We will stay onsite in Disney for 3 nights (4 days) out of the 14 and visit the parks once each and pay for Genie Plus for these specific days only. Additionally paying for 2 x rides per park per day...phew that will really add up so this next visit we will swap most of the table service restaurants for 'snacks' and quick-service meals and have breakfast in the villa as much as we can. We are a family of 6 so it's a lot of money. In previous years (my second visit to Orlando) we did stay in Universal and the unlimited ride ticket was great. Completely different to Genie Plus as you can ride all rides as many times as you want and when you want. Not get up at 7 am to get one ride booked and then see what is available (if anything) for the rest of the day one ride at a time. Of course, I suspect that this is exactly what Disney wants now. Fewer people visiting, less often, spending more money per visit on park entry and rides (as they don't make as much from restaurants etc). Although it will be interesting to see how many people will stay in the parks in the afternoon when presumably the Genie Plus rides have run out and fewer people are staying onsite.
I used to stay onsite, travel free from the airport (as I don't want to drive in the USA), use Disney dining plan, book FP and dining bookings in advance (literally on the first day I could) and never leave Disney for the whole 14 days (just staying in the bubble). Now the bubble has been burst it will be a strange holiday for me. And I confess I would have left it for a few more years to see how things pan out but I have promised the kids so maybe just one more year for us and then we will try something else instead.