Whats your choice for most underated and overated restaurant in WDW????

WDWmazprty

WDWmazprty

Well-Known Member
Original Poster
Ok, so give us your ONE choice for the most underated and the most overated restaurant in WDW and the reason why if you want. Could be QS, TS, whatever.

Let us know, this should be interesting! :lol:

I'll start:

Underated: Kouzzina- We loved the food despite the bad reports, and the restaurant wasnt bad looking.

Overated: So far I have none. :p
 
zurgandfriend

zurgandfriend

Well-Known Member
IMHO
Overrated: Le Cellier, I have eaten there and don’t understand the hype, I know it’s is/was a 1 credit steakhouse but I have had just as good a meal at my underrated pick (s)
Captain’s Grille and Grand Floridian Café - I know you said one each but I consider these tied.
 
disneylemons

disneylemons

Active Member
Under-rated - Tony's Town Square - we ate there for the first time last summer due to not being able to get reservations at other places..and we were very pleasantly surprised. The food was good - atmostphere was fun and the pistachio creme brulee wonderful!

Over-rated - I really love all the places but O'Hana would be one that I thought was a tad over-rated. Atmostphere was good but the food wasn't what I was expecting after reading all the posts - ..:)
 
lebeau

lebeau

Well-Known Member
Over-rated - Le Cellier. Just cause everyone made it out to be a much bigger deal than it is.

Under-rated - This is a tough call but I'm going with Garden Grill. I've seen it get beat up on, but I found the food to be pretty good. The atmosphere was very good and the character interactions were great. I'd head back to Garden Grill before Chef Mickey's.
 
Master Gracey 5

Master Gracey 5

Active Member
Overrated - Mine would be Liberty Tree Tavern. Granted its been a few years since I last ate there, but we've avoided it because that meal was extremely disappointing to us. I've seen some good reviews from others so maybe I'll give it another try in the future, but I think that this one gets grading on a sliding scale because of the lack of TS in MK.

Underrated - I'm going to have to go with Plaza Restaurant here. Definitely a great little place that often gets overlooked for lunch with Tony's and Crystal Palace nearby. Plaza has some great sandwiches and I find the atmosphere charming. Its definitely one of our recent favorites.
 
challisgal

challisgal

New Member
Overrated - O'Hana. The meat was dry, the sides were soupy and the service was indifferent. Every restaurant has an off night and I was only was there once, but I would not go back.

Pinocchio Village Haus - Yes, I know the menu is limited, but I love chicken fingers and I think theirs are great. The pizza is good too and I love the atmosphere. It's counter service, but this is a must stop for every trip.
 
worldfanatic

worldfanatic

Well-Known Member
Overrated - Le Cellier (the obvious choice, nothing else is close)

Underrated - Tokyo Dining (atmosphere, food and service are outstanding)
 
networkpro

networkpro

Well-Known Member
In the Parks
Yes
Over and under (December 2010)

Overrated-Yacht Club Steak House (beef on par with Western Sizzlin, yet $42 bucks a portion)

Underrated- Narcosees' a real actual chef works here so you'll never need to add condiments. My wife loved the shrimp and chowder entree, the surf and turf (best beef on property and thats from a Texas rancher) while I loved the crab crusted flounder with Meyer lemon sauce. Creme Brulee Duo yum!
 
DrummerAlly

DrummerAlly

Well-Known Member
Overrated - Le Chefs de France - good, but maybe our least favorite food on the whole trip

Underrated - The Wave - easily our best meals on the trip from a restaurant we hear so little about. The decor isn't anything special but the food and service were both fantastic.
 
epcotWSC

epcotWSC

Well-Known Member
Overrated: LeCellier - I liked it, but it wasn't as good as it was hyped up to be. Followed closely by Les Chefs De France.

Underrated: None that I've tried so far.
 
brisem

brisem

Well-Known Member
Overrated--Scifi and Primetime --both didnt seem to live up to the hype
Underrated--Garden Grill--not crowded, didn't feel rush to finish
 
britlightyear

britlightyear

Active Member
Overrated- Boma- we have eaten here 3 times because people keep raving about how good it is but each time we have regretted going there :hurl:

Underrated- 1900 Park Fare- we eat here at least 2x every trip and every time has been delicious and the character interaction is amazing. My son has been chosen to dance with Cinderella once and the evil stepmother once. Also the stepsisters are always entertaining :sohappy:
 

Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.

Back
Top Bottom