Phroobar
Well-Known Member
Bring back the Carousel of Progress back to its original home!
Bring back the Carousel of Progress back to its original home!
Even Space Mountain and the Monorail?Literally all of Tomorrowland is fair game for demolition as far as I see it.
Even ... ... the Monorail?
The monorail is historic, not only to Disneyland, but to the entire Western Hemisphere.You mean the hotel transportation system that doesn't actually go to the hotels? ☺
Walt would have gotten rid of it long ago for some new. CoP is extremely dated and no modern audience can relate to it anymore. They are better off with an updated version of Horizons.Yeah I guess you're right. Walt would never have approved of something like the Carousel of Progress.
Carousel of Progress should be preserved but not in the theme parks. Put it at the Walt Disney Family Museum.Walt would have gotten rid of it long ago for some new. CoP is extremely dated and no modern audience can relate to it anymore. They are better off with an updated version of Horizons.
Why? I'd rather see America Sings restored someplace than that old show.Carousel of Progress should be preserved but not in the theme parks. Put it at the Walt Disney Family Museum.
Historical significance to technology and art.Why? I'd rather see America Sings restored someplace than that old show.
Just because it was at a Disney theme park and World's Fair doesn't give it historical significance to make it a historical landmark and definitely doesn't automatically make it art.Historical significance to technology and art.
It's a nice thought, but the many video recordings will do. Like a particular run/cast of a Broadway play, it wasn't meant to last forever, but can be appreciated via Youtube. At least one of the Father AAs (with the dog) should definitely be preserved in a museum, though.Carousel of Progress should be preserved but not in the theme parks. Put it at the Walt Disney Family Museum.
Yeah, but in this case it does. CoP was art and a one-of-a-kind use of tech. Lost a lot after leaving DL, though (see above comment).Just because it was at a Disney theme park and World's Fair doesn't give it historical significance to make it a historical landmark and definitely doesn't automatically make it art.
Okay, did you ever see America Sings in person? 'Cause if you did, you know that show had some pacing and sound design issues. I loved the show, too, but some of the gags were really, really cringe-inducing. I'd vote the "Old Grey Mare" as the single most awful, irritating, obnoxious AA character in DL's history. Seriously, I'd put my hands over my eyes and sink down in my seat every time she'd rise up out of the stage to deliver her loud, super-unfunny routine. It must have looked good on paper...Why? I'd rather see America Sings restored someplace than that old show.
Maybe so but that still doesn't mean it should occupy that much space in Tomorrowland. If it was restored and even updated a little, it would have the same number of people watching it as Lincoln gets in a day. That's a huge foot print that could easily be used as a people eater ride for something people would actually enjoy. Horizons 2.0 would fit the bill a lot better and could provide a cool thrill element that CoP could never do.Yeah, but in this case it does. CoP was art and a one-of-a-kind use of tech. Lost a lot after leaving DL, though (see above comment).
Yes I saw it many times and loved it as a kid. It was a like a living cartoon. It's something I associated Disneyland with. Sure it was cheesy but so was most of Disneyland. Even POTC and HM has it's share of cringe and cheese.Okay, did you ever see America Sings in person? 'Cause if you did, you know that show had some pacing and sound design issues. I loved the show, too, but some of the gags were really, really cringe-inducing. I'd vote the "Old Grey Mare" as the single most awful, irritating, obnoxious AA character in DL's history. Seriously, I'd put my hands over my eyes and sink down in my seat every time she'd rise up out of the stage to deliver her loud, super-unfunny routine. It must have looked good on paper...
If PoTC and HM have a slice of cheese each , AS was the Tillamook cheese factory tour. I'm kidding: I loved America Sings. But... I think at least 1/3 of the show was groan-inducing (and again with the multiple alcholism-is-funny gags!) ... but the other 2/3 was pretty great.Yes I saw it many times and loved it as a kid. It was a like a living cartoon. It's something I associated Disneyland with. Sure it was cheesy but so was most of Disneyland. Even POTC and HM has it's share of cringe and cheese.
Don't forget about the line about adultery that they removed for one that was totally racist. AS was definitely not PC.If PoTC and HM have a slice of cheese each , AS was the Tillamook cheese factory tour. I'm kidding: I loved America Sings. But... I think at least 1/3 of the show was groan-inducing (and again with the multiple alcholism-is-funny gags!) ... but the other 2/3 was pretty great.
Register on WDWMAGIC. This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.