I agree about your thoughts on the Galloway being too much and not enough at the same time @
Ariel484. I was looking at the Galloway marathon plan and the last high mileage week for the non beginner plan is 29 miles. And he suggests you do it 1-2 minutes slower than race pace. That means a long run of about 7 hours for me and it falls, in December when we only have about 8 hours of daylight to start with! I have concocted my own plan taking parts and pieces of several and so far it seems to be working for me.
5 days a week would be an impossible goal for me. I just have too much going on, a full time job, a part time job, single mom on weekdays etc...I have read over and over that the long run is the most important run of training. So my plan is Mondays 7-10 miles, Wedsnesdays 3-5 miles and Friday long runs increasing to a maximum of 24 miles 3 weeks before the marathon. I also have a 3-4 mile run every other Sunday on the weekends I don't work.
So my maximum weekly mileage will be 38 Currently I am running between 14 and 17 miles a week, I figured out a plan where my mileage will increase about 2% every week with a drop back of 5% every third week.
I printed out a bunch of blank calendar pages along with several different training plans; Galloway intermediate, Higdon intermediate 1, and runners world intermediate, them i got out the calculator to see what they all had in common for weekly mileage increases...then I mapped it out for my hectic life. I am a little bit of a type A planner myself, I have to be or chaos will reign.
Anyway I started this a month ago and since then I haven't had any pains from doing too much too fast. I have until January so I am feeling good since my long runs are up to 10 miles already, Galloway week one was last week and the first long run is 5.5. But I am going to step it up slowly, when I reach 20 mikes I am going to plateau there for a few weeks.
The first marathon I did, my training plan worked up to 20 in three weeks after 14 and then began to taper. I didn't really feel too strong during that last 6 miles since I had never run that far and I definitely hit a wall and had to walk for a bit.
I could go on for hours about this subject because training plans fascinate me