The fact that 80% of a ride capacity is given to FP+ is a real problem to anyone who doesn’t have an FP for that attraction. Many people also dislike having to plan so far out to book their FP+. And of course those who stay onsite and find they still can’t book a Fastpass for FoP or Smuggler’s Run or FEA get doubly upset.
Even avid planners can dislike FP+ whilst still taking advantage of it. Personally I actually agree with
@JaxFLBear , in that I enjoy being able to plan my days knowing that I can get an FP for all the family’s favourite rides (and shows). That doesn’t mean I can’t see the downsides of FP+, although I have benefitted from it.
But your insistence that you
must be able to skip the lines for X, Y & Z rides is puzzling. You can’t know before you book that you will be able to do that. It doesn’t matter what system they have in place. All you can do is book and then cancel if you are unable to get an FP or skip the line in some other way. Even booking a VIP tour means waiting until you can book a tour and hoping there is availability.