Now you're just saying stuff to be controversial. It's impossible for me to conceive that anyone could fail to be impressed by these incredible singers. Maybe you've got a problem with their selection of songs, and I can see that (Oh Susannah needs to be retired). But overall they are pretty incredible!
Nope, this is my honest opinion, and it has nothing to do with song selection. I've never liked that fake, sugary-sweet pop sound and have never felt it fit in with their period dress, patriotic song selection or the rotunda setting. I believe I have described the LS as what a Hallmark Card from the late 70s would sound like.
I do have an appreciation the talent of the singers themselves. My wife was a voice major and one of her friends was a LS. I was at her senior recital and let me tell you, I teared up because of her beautiful voice. She could sing in ANY opera around the world. But, no, she was forced to modify her voice to fit the LS sound. Those are NOT their natural singing voices, and LS would be so much better if they could sing the way they were born to sing.
I'm surprised by this because I pretty much hate all shows but I actually liked that one.
1) I always thought reusing the old parade floats was cheap and lazy compared to the puppets from the old Legend of the Lion King show at Magic Kingdom.
2) The script and behavior of the 4 hosts always seemed "stereotypical African" to me, and having the plus size singer represent the Warthog section by leading us in making pig oinks and snorts was personally offensive to my wife and I.
Maybe something has changed in the 10 years since we last saw it with the move to the new theater, but I don't want to risk it to find out.
I would have much prefered a condensed version of the Broadway Show (ala Finding Nemo The Musical) than this.