Now we're talking big picture stuff and that is hard to quantify. Oftentimes in these arguments, everyone makes valid points and this is an example of this. I do think the view of WDW isn't as rosy in the general population as it used to be based on many interactions with people. However, Mr. Jakeman is also right. The doom of the Disney themed recreational areas seems to be far away and almost certainly not on the horizon despite predictions of constant doom
I think it's hyperbole if people talk like the whole thing shutting down.. but the place the product has in people's lives, how they approach it, etc.. I think that is already happening. I think you have four types of people
- people who would never give Disney a chance period
- people who aspire to visit disney based on what they've heard about it
- people who visit disney as a vacation option among other options
- people who visit disney and continue to visit disney and find it to be their peak spot
The second group is the funnel that Disney built with it's reputation. It's also the group that is vunerable to bad press, shifting interests, and the one that Disney's image impacts the most. The third group is going to exist as long as Disney puts out a 'good enough' product, even if they are down compared to what they were before. The fourth group is the one that is vunerable to Disney dropping its standards and how it treats customers.
Disney can torpedo the fourth group... while still having plenty of runway from the 2nd and 3rd group.. but they will shrink the 4th that was their base and some of their best customers. If they hurt the 3rd and 4th group.. they start to impact their funnel in the 2nd group. It takes awhile, but that erosion works its way through.
I mean you can see the change even in members here... customers that used to treat WDW like heaven... now are skeptics and often shake off the negatives to focus on the positives they still hold dear.
I think alot of the 'lifer' based of that fourth group has been weakened. The reality is Disney built up so much in it's first 80 years of life, it takes a lot to wear that down when there isn't drastic, brutal change.
The change is going to be seen in the types of champions Disney builds now.. vs what they had in the past. It will take a lot more to move the needle dramatically on the less faithful.. because of the image Disney has built, and the funnel they still maintain OUTSIDE the parks.. with things like The Disney Channel, Disney Music, etc.