Yeah - the author clearly doesn't know anything about the club or how it works.
The bottom line is that a major perk has been removed - and that major perk was THE SELLING POINT they used to get members who were previously paying $3-4K a year to upgrade and pay $12-13K/per year. As a result, many of them have reverted to the lower tier membership - the Disney bait and switch technique employed so well at WDW went over like a fart in church with club members.
So they're now paying MORE for LESS. Sound familiar to anyone who visits WDW?
Feelings about the 1% or whatever aside, it's emblematic of a bigger problem. The letter they sent members said the benefits were being "enhanced" - who writes this stuff with a straight face? It's a flat out lie - there were no new benefits or enhancements, just a price hike with a major benefit deletion.
Club members are some of the park's biggest fans (whales in Vegas parlance) who drop thousands and thousands each year on merch, events and dining. In the past two years, Colglazier's pet project of revamping Club 33 has seen the members be treated horribly. Colglazier and his friends should attend some classes from Vegas casinos on how to treat whales - they're failing on a big scale.
The new lounge will now be empty almost all of the time. Enjoy the lost drink and food revenue TDA!