Thanks ladies!
Dryerlintfan- I accidentally poured an extra 3/4 cup water in. Tried to make it up with powdered sugar, but didn’t add any more meringue. That’s what ruined the consistency.
Then I added the blue coloring to the main white frosting batch— not even thinking that it was the big bowl and NOT the small bowl. At that point I didn’t have enough supplies to make another double batch. They’re edible, but they’re not very good!!
Here’s what they were supposed to be- white jersey, sleeve, name, and ‘8’ drawn on with an edible marker.
View attachment 278805
Here’s what I sent to school-
View attachment 278804
Anyway, thanks for listening to my failures once again.. and for giving support!
The rest of the day should be hiccup free.